
The Supreme Court has held that the supply and installation of solar power generating systems under EPC contracts does not constitute a 'works contract' under the CGST Act, as SPG systems are movable property. The Court further ruled that the 70:30 valuation ratio introduced prospectively from 1 January 2019 cannot be mandatorily applied to prior transactions, and Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST merely offered an option to assessees. The appeal against the Bombay High Court's dismissal of the writ petition is allowed, setting aside tax demands of ₹53.35 crore.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The appellant, M/s. Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd., is engaged in the supply and installation of Solar Power Generating Systems (SPG systems) on a turnkey basis through Engineering-Procurement-Construction (EPC) contracts across various States. During the period 1 July 2017 to 31 December 2018, the appellant discharged GST at 5% (2.5% CGST + 2.5% SGST) on the entire contract value, treating the supply as goods falling under Serial No. 234 of Schedule I to Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28 June 2017. The revenue authorities, however, contended that the transaction was a composite supply in the nature of a works contract under Section 2(119) of the CGST Act, attracting 18% GST on the services component.
Key Facts
- The appellant executed EPC contracts for supply and installation of SPG systems at customer-specified locations during 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018.
- Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 placed 'Solar power generating system' at Serial No. 234 in Schedule I, attracting 2.5% CGST (5% GST with SGST).
- Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate) dated 31.12.2018 inserted an Explanation to Serial No. 234, deeming 70% of gross consideration as value of goods (5% GST) and 30% as value of taxable services (18% GST), effective 01.01.2019.
- Notification No. 27/2018-Central Tax (Rate) dated 31.12.2018 inserted Serial No. 38 in Notification No. 11/2017 for construction/installation services related to renewable energy devices, at 9% CGST (18% GST), effective 01.01.2019.
- Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST dated 06.10.2021 clarified that assessees "can" pay GST at the 70:30 ratio for the period 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018, but no refunds would be granted if tax had already been paid at a higher rate.
- The Joint Commissioner, CGST & CX, Thane, passed order dated 17.01.2025 demanding CGST of ₹13,33,95,241 with penalty of ₹26,67,90,482, plus equivalent SGST and penalty, totalling ₹53,35,80,964, invoking extended limitation under Section 74 CGST Act on grounds of wilful misstatement.
- The Superintendent, Range V, Santacruz, issued a consequential Summary Order dated 24.01.2025.
- The Andhra Pradesh High Court, in a parallel case involving the same appellant (Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner, State Tax, Vijayawada, decided 10.01.2025), held that SPG systems are not immovable property and the transaction is not a works contract.
Procedural History
- 29.03.2023: Show cause-cum-demand notice issued to the appellant.
- 17.01.2025: Joint Commissioner, CGST & CX, Thane passed the impugned order confirming tax demand and penalty.
- 24.01.2025: Superintendent, Range V, Santacruz issued Summary Order for recovery.
- 2025: Writ Petition No. 4616 of 2025 filed before the Bombay High Court challenging both orders.
- 28.07.2025: Bombay High Court dismissed the writ petition on the ground of availability of an efficacious alternate remedy (statutory appeal), noting no contention on why the rule of exhaustion should be bypassed and that pre-deposit was not harsh.
- 25.08.2025: Supreme Court stayed the operation of the order dated 17.01.2025.
- 16.11.2026: Supreme Court pronounced judgment allowing the appeal.
Relief Sought
The appellant sought quashing of the orders dated 17.01.2025 and 24.01.2025, a declaration that the supply and installation of SPG systems during 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018 attracts GST at 5% on the full value under Serial No. 234 of Notification No. 1/2017, and that the 70:30 ratio under Notification No. 24/2018 is not mandatorily applicable to the pre-2019 period.
The Legal Issue
The central questions were: (1) Whether the supply and installation of SPG systems under EPC contracts constitutes a 'works contract' under Section 2(119) of the CGST Act, which turns on whether the end product is immovable property; (2) Whether the 70:30 valuation ratio introduced by Notification No. 24/2018 with effect from 01.01.2019 can be mandatorily applied to transactions prior to that date; (3) Whether Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST mandated the 70:30 ratio for the prior period or merely offered an option; and (4) Whether the invocation of extended limitation under Section 74 CGST Act on grounds of fraud/wilful misstatement was sustainable.
Arguments Presented
For the Appellant
The appellant contended that the transaction was a composite supply of goods (SPG systems) with installation services, where the principal supply was goods falling under Serial No. 234 at 5% GST. It relied on the Andhra Pradesh High Court's decision dated 10.01.2025 in its own case, which held that SPG systems are not immovable property, applying the tests from Bharti Airtel Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune (2024) 19 SCC 1. The appellant argued that Notification No. 24/2018 was prospective, Circular No. 163/19/2021 used the word "can" indicating an option, and the authorities erroneously converted an option into a mandate. It further submitted that no fraud or wilful misstatement could be alleged for a period when the 70:30 regime did not exist.
For the Respondent
The Revenue contended that the supply and installation of SPG systems was a composite supply in the nature of a works contract under Section 2(119) CGST Act, as the end product was immovable property. It argued that SPG systems are permanently embedded in the earth via civil foundations, relying on TTG Industries Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise, Raipur (2004) 4 SCC 751. The Revenue maintained that Circular No. 163/19/2021 clarified the applicable rate for the pre-2019 period and that the appellant's classification at 5% on the full value was a deliberate suppression attracting Section 74.
The Court's Analysis
The Court examined the definition of 'works contract' under Section 2(119) CGST Act, which requires the contract to relate to building, construction, erection, etc., of immovable property involving transfer of property in goods. It contrasted this with 'composite supply' under Section 2(30), noting from Note 6 of Schedule II that every works contract is a composite supply but not vice versa. The distinction, as articulated by the Andhra Pradesh High Court, lies in whether the end product is immovable property.
The Court reviewed the line of precedents on the test for immovable property. In Commissioner of Central Excise, Ahmedabad v. Solid and Correct Engineering Works (2010) 5 SCC 122, it was held that attachment by nuts and bolts to a shallow foundation for operational stability does not amount to 'attached to the earth' under Section 3(26) General Clauses Act, 1897. Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise, Hyderabad (1998) 1 SCC 400 established that mere fixation for operational efficiency does not convert machinery into immovable property. Duncans Industries Ltd. v. State of U.P. (2000) 1 SCC 633 emphasized the intention of the parties and facts of each case.
Critically, in Bharti Airtel Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune (2024) 19 SCC 1, the Court summarised six tests: (1) Nature of annexation; (2) Object of annexation; (3) Intendment of the parties; (4) Functionality test; (5) Permanency test; (6) Marketability test. Applying these, the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Sterling and Wilson (10.01.2025) and Siemens Gamesa Renewable Power Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner ST (2025) 12 TMI 1888 held that solar panels and wind turbines attached to foundations for their own stability and efficiency, capable of dismantling and relocation without damage, are movable property. The Supreme Court in Assistant Commissioner ST v. Siemens Gamesa (2026) 8 TMI 847 dismissed the Revenue's challenge, affirming this view.
The Court found that the SPG systems installed by the appellant can be detached from civil foundations and used elsewhere; the foundation serves the system, not vice versa. The attachment is for the beneficial enjoyment of the SPG system, not the land. Therefore, the transaction is not a works contract.
On the 70:30 ratio, the Court held that Notification No. 24/2018 came into force on 01.01.2019 with no retrospective operation. Circular No. 163/19/2021, issued under Section 168 CGST Act, stated that GST "can" be paid at the 70:30 ratio for the prior period, indicating an option. The authorities' interpretation converting "can" into a mandate was "patently erroneous and wholly unsustainable." Since the 70:30 regime did not exist during 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018, no fraud or wilful misstatement could be imputed, rendering the invocation of Section 74 and extended limitation completely unsustainable, as also noted in M/s Tata Steel Ltd. v. Union of India (2026) 8 TMI 1587.
The Court also noted that Notification No. 8/2021 dated 30.09.2021 substituted 'solar power generating system' with 'solar power generator' in Schedule II, confirming that the earlier entry treated the entire SPG system as a unit, and this substitution cannot apply retrospectively.
"The notion of the authorities that the option given to the assessees, whereby they could adopt the 70:30 ratio even for supplies made prior to 01.01.2019, should be mandatorily applied across the board even to assessees who did not choose that option, is patently erroneous and wholly unsustainable."
The Verdict
The appeal is allowed. The Supreme Court set aside the order dated 17.01.2025 passed by the Joint Commissioner, CGST & CX, Thane Commissionerate, and the consequential Summary Order dated 24.01.2025 passed by the Superintendent, Range V, Santacruz, Mumbai. The tax demand of ₹53,35,80,964 (comprising CGST ₹13,33,95,241, CGST penalty ₹26,67,90,482, and equivalent SGST and penalty) is quashed. The Court held that the supply and installation of SPG systems during 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018 attracts GST at 5% on the full value under Serial No. 234 of Notification No. 1/2017, the 70:30 ratio is not mandatorily applicable to the pre-2019 period, and no penalty or extended limitation can be invoked. Parties shall bear their own costs.
What This Means For Similar Cases
70:30 Ratio Is Optional, Not Mandatory, for Pre-2019 Period
- Assessees who supplied renewable energy devices under EPC contracts before 01.01.2019 cannot be compelled to adopt the 70:30 valuation ratio introduced by Notification No. 24/2018.
- Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST uses the word "can," conferring a choice on the assessee; the revenue cannot convert this option into a statutory mandate.
- Practitioners should challenge any demand that applies the 70:30 ratio retrospectively without the assessee's election.
SPG Systems and Similar Renewable Energy Installations Are Movable Property
- The six-fold test from Bharti Airtel (nature of annexation, object, intendment, functionality, permanency, marketability) is the governing framework.
- Where equipment is attached to a foundation solely for its own operational stability, can be dismantled and relocated without damage, and the parties intend no permanent addition to the land, the property remains movable.
- This principle extends to wind turbine generators (Siemens Gamesa) and solar pumping systems (Arka Green Power).
No Fraud or Extended Limitation Where Regime Did Not Exist
- Section 74 CGST Act (extended limitation for fraud/wilful misstatement/suppression) cannot be invoked for a period when the alleged misclassification relates to a valuation mechanism (70:30 ratio) that did not legally exist.
- The foundational facts for fraud must be evident from the show cause notice; mere use of epithets like "wilful misstatement" without application of mind is insufficient (Tata Steel).
- Practitioners should scrutinise Section 74 invocations where the underlying legal basis for the demand is itself questionable.
Statutory Appeal Not a Bar to Writ Jurisdiction Where Arguable Points Exist
- The Supreme Court reiterated that availability of an alternate remedy is not a "strait jacketed formula"; High Courts must examine arguable points on merits rather than mechanically dismissing writ petitions.
- Where a Division Bench of another High Court has already adjudicated the identical issue in the same assessee's favour, the Supreme Court may decide the matter itself to avoid remand.
Notification Substitutions Confirm Legislative Intent on Unit of Taxation
- The replacement of 'solar power generating system' with 'solar power generator' in Notification No. 8/2021 confirms that the pre-2019 regime treated the entire SPG system as a single taxable unit at 5%.
- Such substitutions cannot be applied retrospectively to alter the tax incidence on past transactions.






