Case Law Analysis

Trade Marks Act Section 57 | Prior User Rights Prevail Over Later Registration of Identical Mark; ED Attachment No Bar to Rectification : Delhi HC

The Delhi High Court cancelled the 'NAWAJISH' trademark for rice, upholding Dunar Foods' prior use since 2007 and ruling that prior user rights prevail over later registration of identical marks under Section 57. The court held that Enforcement Directorate attachment of the prior user's assets does not bar rectification, safeguarding vested rights against subsequent registrants.

Cassie News NetworkCassie News Network
Nov 19, 2026, 12:17 AM
•9 min read
Be the first to share in your circle
Trade Marks Act Section 57 | Prior User Rights Prevail Over Later Registration of Identical Mark; ED Attachment No Bar to Rectification : Delhi HC

The Delhi High Court has cancelled the trademark registration of "NAWAJISH" with device "N" for basmati rice under Class 30, holding that Dunar Foods Limited's prior adoption and continuous use since 2007 prevails over Ankit Vats' subsequent registration obtained on a proposed-to-be-used basis in 2017. The Court rejected a maintainability objection founded on Enforcement Directorate attachment proceedings, ruling that such attachment does not extinguish intellectual property rights or bar a company from invoking rectification jurisdiction under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

Background & Facts

The Dispute

Dunar Foods Limited, a major manufacturer and exporter of premium basmati rice tracing its lineage to an enterprise established in 1956, claimed prior adoption of the distinctive coined mark "NAWAJISH/NAWAZISH" for rice and allied products under Class 30 from 2007. The company discovered in 2024 that Ankit Vats, trading as AVJK Foods LLP, was marketing identical goods under a deceptively similar mark and artistic trade dress bearing the registration for "NAWAJISH" with device mark "N" obtained in 2017 on a proposed-to-be-used basis. After a cease-and-desist notice went unheeded, Dunar Foods filed a petition under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 seeking cancellation of Ankit Vats' registration. Ankit Vats responded with a cross-petition seeking cancellation of Dunar Foods' trademark.

Key Facts

  • Dunar Foods' corporate predecessor, Dulichand Narender Kumar Exports Private Limited (renamed Dunar Foods Limited on 29.12.2010), filed Application No. 1550388 for "NAWAJISH" on 17.04.2007, which proceeded to registration on 31.03.2009.
  • A subsequent application (No. 2055689) for the stylized and device representation of the mark was filed on 19.11.2010 claiming user from 13.10.2007; registered on 29.05.2015 with a clerical error ("NAWAGISH") later rectified.
  • Ankit Vats filed Application No. 3578464 for "NAWAJISH" with device mark "N" on 26.06.2017 on a "proposed to be used" basis; Registration Certificate No. 1741844 issued thereafter.
  • Both registrations cover identical goods: rice falling under Class 30.
  • "NAWAJISH" is not a common dictionary word but a distinctive, arbitrary term integral to Dunar Foods' brand identity.
  • Ankit Vats offered no explanation for adopting the identical coined mark for identical goods.
  • Enforcement Directorate provisional attachment orders were issued against Dunar Foods during corporate resolution proceedings, directing no third-party interest creation in intellectual property without designated court permission.

Procedural History

  • 2024: Dunar Foods issued legal cease-and-desist notice to Ankit Vats; non-compliance led to filing of C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 158/2024 with I.A. 36142/2024, I.A. 36143/2024, I.A. 10268/2026, I.A. 18994/2026 & I.A. 21408/2026.
  • 2024: Ankit Vats filed cross-petition C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 203/2024 with I.A. 42370/2024 & I.A. 42371/2024.
  • 27.10.2026: Matters reserved for judgment.
  • 17.11.2026: Judgment pronounced (16.11.2026 was a holiday on account of Chhath Puja).

Relief Sought

Dunar Foods sought cancellation of Ankit Vats' registration (Application No. 3578464, Registration Certificate No. 1741844) for "NAWAJISH" with device "N" in Class 30. Ankit Vats sought cancellation of Dunar Foods' trademark registrations and challenged maintainability of Dunar Foods' petition citing MPID Act and ED proceedings.

The Court had to resolve three core questions: (1) Whether Enforcement Directorate attachment proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 and the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors Act, 1999 strip a company of locus standi to maintain trademark rectification proceedings under Section 57; (2) Whether Ankit Vats' registration for "NAWAJISH" with device "N" for rice (Class 30) is valid given Dunar Foods' established prior use since 2007; (3) Whether minor variations - a device featuring the letter "N" and the substitution of "Z" for "J" - suffice to distinguish phonetically and visually identical marks for identical goods.

Arguments Presented

For the Petitioner (Dunar Foods Limited)

Ms. Swathi Sukumar, Senior Counsel, submitted that Dunar Foods is the prior adopter, continuous user, and registered proprietor since April 2007 - nearly a decade before Ankit Vats' 2017 application. She contended that registration of a similar mark for identical goods violates Sections 9(1)(a), 9(2)(a), 11(1), 11(3), 11(10) and 18(4) of the Trade Marks Act. The alleged non-use by Dunar Foods was characterised as an afterthought, sufficiently rebutted by documentary evidence. Reliance was placed on Blue Heaven Cosmetics Pvt. Ltd. v. Deepak Arora, Russell Corp Australia Pty. Ltd. v. Ashok Mahajan, and Dorco Co. Ltd. v. Durga Enterprises to establish that a subsequent trader's adoption of an identical mark without plausible explanation constitutes dishonest usurpation of goodwill.

For the Respondent (Ankit Vats trading as AVJK Foods LLP)

Mr. Utsav Jain raised a preliminary objection to maintainability, arguing that the Economic Offence Wing notice dated 01.02.2016 and ED action under PMLA without express permission from the designated MPID Special Court under Section 10 of the MPID Act deprived Dunar Foods of locus standi. On merits, he contended that Ankit Vats enjoys honest concurrent user rights under a specially crafted device mark featuring the letter "N", citing various decisions in support.

The Court's Analysis

The Court first dismissed the maintainability objection. It held that intellectual property rights protection through legal proceedings is neither interdicted nor restricted by provisional attachment orders. Citing Rajiv Chakraborty Resolution Professional of EEIL v. Directorate of Enforcement, the Court observed:

"Attachment is not liable to be viewed as an effacement of all rights that may exist or be claimed by an individual. It is essentially a fetter placed upon the possessor of that property to deal with the same till such time as proceedings under the aforesaid enactment come to a definitive conclusion."

On the scope of Section 57, the Court affirmed its power to expunge entries made without sufficient cause or wrongly remaining on the Register. Following Blue Heaven Cosmetics and Russell Corp, it held that where a mark is registered in violation of absolute or relative grounds for refusal, it stands "wrongly entered and wrongly remaining" and warrants direct cancellation. The adoption of an identical or deceptively similar mark for identical goods by a subsequent trader without bona fide justification constitutes a dishonest attempt to usurp the prior proprietor's reputation.

Comparing the rival marks and trade dress, the Court found them phonetically and visually identical. The device mark "N" in Ankit Vats' packaging fails to create meaningful differentiation, especially since consumers rarely undertake thorough comparison in the marketplace. The substitution of "Z" for "J" is phonetically negligible and appears calculative to pass off Dunar Foods' goods. Such minor tweaks, viewed against Dunar Foods' long-standing prior use, indicate deliberate adoption.

On evidence of prior use, the Court traced Dunar Foods' corporate lineage to 1956, formalisation in 1997, and name change in 2010. The 2007 application with user claim from 13.10.2007, registration in 2009, and subsequent device registration in 2015 conclusively establish prior commercial adoption well over a decade before Ankit Vats' 2017 proposed-use application. Conversely, Ankit Vats offered no explanation for adopting the identical coined term. Citing Dorco Co. Ltd., the Court held that absence of any explanation regarding adoption renders the application in contravention of Section 18(1).

Finally, the Court affirmed the supremacy of prior user rights over later registration. Reading Sections 27, 28 and 34 together, as endorsed in S. Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai, the scheme of the Act recognises prior user rights as superior to registration. Use of an identical mark by a later registrant for identical goods is likely to deceive the public and cause confusion, actionable under passing off and barred by Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(3)(a). As held in Amit Sood v. Union of India, any mark resulting in passing off would not be liable to registration.

The Verdict

The Court allowed C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 158/2024 filed by Dunar Foods Limited. The registration of the impugned mark "NAWAZISH" bearing Application No. 3578464 in Class 30 along with Registration Certificate No. 1741844 in the Register of Trade Marks is cancelled and set aside. All pending applications in that matter stand disposed of. The cross-petition C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 203/2024 filed by Ankit Vats is dismissed for failure to make out any case for interference; all pending applications therein also stand disposed of. The date fixed before the Joint Registrar on 22.01.2027 in both matters stands cancelled.

What This Means For Similar Cases

Attachment Proceedings Do Not Extinguish IP Rights

Provisional attachment orders under PMLA or MPID Act fetter the possessor's ability to alienate property but do not efface substantive intellectual property rights. A company under attachment retains locus standi to enforce its trademarks through rectification, opposition, or infringement proceedings. Practitioners should not concede maintainability objections based solely on ED or EOW actions; the fetter is on alienation, not on legal enforcement of existing rights.

Prior User Rights Trump Later Registration

The judgment reinforces that prior adoption and continuous use, even without registration, confer superior rights over a subsequent registrant. When a later applicant adopts an identical coined mark for identical goods on a proposed-to-be-used basis without any plausible explanation, the inference of dishonest adoption is nearly irresistible. Practitioners advising prior users should meticulously document the chain of use - invoices, advertisements, regulatory filings, corporate lineage - from the earliest possible date.

Minor Device Variations Cannot Distinguish Identical Marks

A single-letter device feature (here, the letter "N") or a phonetically irrelevant spelling variation ("Z" for "J") is insufficient to avert consumer confusion when the dominant word element is identical and the goods are the same. Courts assess marks from the perspective of an average consumer with imperfect recollection. In clearance searches and opposition proceedings, focus on the dominant, distinctive component of the mark rather than peripheral design elements.

  • Actionable takeaway: Before filing a trademark application, conduct a comprehensive prior-use search covering not just the Register but market evidence (trade directories, export data, domain registrations, social media). A proposed-to-use application for a mark already in established commercial use by another in the same class is vulnerable to cancellation under Section 57.
  • Actionable takeaway: In rectification proceedings, lead with documentary proof of prior use (dated invoices, purchase orders, advertising spend, regulatory licences) rather than relying solely on registration certificates. The Court's analysis here turned on the 2007 application with a 13.10.2007 user claim, corroborated by corporate history.
  • Actionable takeaway: When facing a maintainability challenge based on attachment or insolvency proceedings, cite Rajiv Chakraborty to establish that the fetter is on disposition, not on the assertion of legal rights in appropriate forums.

Case Details

ANKIT VATS TRADING AS AVJK FOODS LLP vs DUNAR FOODS LIMITED & ANR.

2026:DHC:10204
PDF
Court
Delhi High Court
Date
2026-11-17
Case Number
COT - 203/2024
Bench
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
Counsel
Pet: Swathi Sukumar, Junaid Alam, S. Nithin, Rishika Aggarwal, Nishant Mattha
Res: Utsav Jain, Hemant Singh, Urvashi Jain, Aman Bidhuri, Attrey Gupta

Frequently Asked Questions

No. The Delhi High Court held that attachment is a fetter on the possessor's power to deal with the property, not an effacement of substantive rights. A company under attachment retains locus standi to enforce its intellectual property rights through legal proceedings, including rectification under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
The registration is liable to cancellation. The Court held that adoption of an identical coined mark for identical goods without any plausible explanation constitutes a dishonest attempt to usurp the prior user's reputation. Prior user rights under Sections 27, 28 and 34 of the Trade Marks Act are superior to the rights of a later registrant.
No. The Court found that the device mark "N" and the substitution of "Z" for "J" are phonetically and visually negligible. Consumers rarely undertake thorough comparison; such minor variations are insufficient to avert confusion when the dominant word element and goods are identical.
The Court relied on a chain of documentary evidence: trademark applications with user claims (2007 application claiming use from 13.10.2007), registration certificates, corporate lineage documents (1956 enterprise, 1997 incorporation, 2010 name change), and the absence of any explanation from the later adopter for choosing the identical coined term.
0

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The views expressed are based on the judgment analysis and should not be taken as professional counsel. Please consult with a qualified attorney for advice specific to your situation.