
The Supreme Court has held that acts of forgery, fabrication of documents, and manipulation of revenue records by a public servant do not fall within the discharge of official duties, rendering the protection of Section 197 CrPC and the Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) CrPC inapplicable. The Court set aside the Bombay High Court's order quashing criminal proceedings against a City Survey Officer, restoring the trial for offences under Sections 465, 466, 468, 471, 474, 420, 120B and 34 IPC.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The appellant, Ashok, trustee of the Priyadarshini Charitable Trust, challenged the Bombay High Court's order dated 27.11.2024 which quashed criminal proceedings pending against Respondent No. 1, Mahesh Fulpagare (City Survey Officer, Dhule), in RCC No. 1020 of 2023 and RCC No. 119 of 2024 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhule. The chargesheets alleged offences under Sections 465, 466, 468, 471, 474, 420, 120B and 34 IPC for conspiring to prepare forged documents, falsely presenting them as genuine, and manipulating property records to fraudulently transfer trust property.
Key Facts
- On 18.09.1992, the Priyadarshini Charitable Trust received land parcel admeasuring 21,000 sq.ft. (City Survey No. 1888) as gift from Avdhut Anant Adavadkar and others through Gopal Anant Adavadkar holding General Power of Attorney; appropriate mutation was made in favour of the Trust.
- Special Civil Suit No. 53 of 2003 was filed by original owners seeking partition of land in Devpur, Dhule (Survey Nos. 42/2 and 44/7), including declaration that sale deed dated 20.06.1992 to Shri Swami Samarth Co-op Housing Society Limited was void.
- On 01.08.2018, the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dhule decreed the suit and declared the deeds void, including the sale deed of 20.06.1992.
- On the same day, Dinkar Anantrao Adavadkar (Accused No. 1) applied to the City Survey Officer for mutation in his name based on the decree; the application was allegedly unsigned and incomplete.
- Respondent No. 1 (City Survey Officer) and Accused No. 3 (Examination Surveyor) allegedly made illegal mutation entry (Mutation Entry No. 7062) on 16.11.2018, removing the Trust's name and recording names of Accused No. 1 and 18 others.
- The appellant sent notice to Respondent No. 1 and Accused No. 3 on 19.12.2018 apprising them of the different nature of properties; they replied on 29.12.2018 stating no notice was required.
- On 02.01.2019, the appellant attempted to lodge an FIR; upon police inaction, filed private complaints under Section 156(3) CrPC: Criminal Misc. Application No. 323 of 2019 (as trustee) and No. 421 of 2019 (as Secretary of Shri Swami Samarth Co-op Housing Society).
- On 11.07.2019, the appellant applied to the Settlement Commissioner and Director of Land Records (Maharashtra State) for sanction to prosecute Respondent No. 1 and Accused No. 3.
- On 30.11.2019, the District Superintendent of Land Records, Dhule allowed Appeal No. 214 of 2019 and directed cancellation of Mutation Entry No. 7062.
- On 17.03.2020, JMFC Dhule directed investigation under Section 156(3) CrPC in Criminal Misc. Application No. 323 of 2019, finding prima facie case for offences under Sections 465, 466, 468, 471, 474, 420, 120B read with Section 34 IPC.
- FIR No. 79 of 2020 registered on 20.03.2020 at Dhule City Police Station; Respondent No. 1 and Accused No. 3 arrested same day.
- On 05.08.2020, Settlement Commissioner and Director of Land Records suspended Respondent No. 1 after noting FIR registration and custody exceeding 48 hours.
- On 13.08.2020, Respondent No. 1 filed Criminal Application No. 1371 of 2020 before High Court seeking quashment of FIR No. 79 of 2020.
- On 04.03.2021, JMFC Dhule directed investigation under Section 156(3) CrPC in Criminal Misc. Application No. 421 of 2019, finding prima facie case against Accused Nos. 1 to 3.
- FIR No. 62 of 2021 registered on 06.03.2021 at Dhule City Police Station; Respondent No. 1 was Accused No. 2.
- On 17.12.2021, Respondent No. 1 filed Criminal Application No. 3235 of 2021 before High Court seeking quashment of FIR No. 62 of 2021.
- Chargesheet filed on 21.12.2023 in case arising from FIR No. 79 of 2020 (RCC No. 1020 of 2023) alleging tampering of application, forged documents, and conspiracy to transfer property.
- Chargesheet filed on 12.02.2024 in case arising from FIR No. 62 of 2021 (RCC No. 119 of 2024) alleging fraudulent manipulation of property records for Survey Nos. 1889, 4460, 4496 belonging to Shri Swami Samarth Cooperative Housing Society.
- High Court by order dated 27.11.2024 allowed both applications, quashing proceedings on ground that sanction under Section 197 CrPC read with Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) was required and not obtained from competent authority.
Procedural History
- 18.09.1992: Gift deed executed in favour of Priyadarshini Charitable Trust
- 2003: Special Civil Suit No. 53 of 2003 filed
- 01.08.2018: Civil Judge decreed suit, declared deeds void
- 01.08.2018: Accused No. 1 applied for mutation
- 16.11.2018: Mutation Entry No. 7062 approved
- 19.12.2018: Appellant sent notice to Respondent No. 1 and Accused No. 3
- 29.12.2018: Reply received from Respondent No. 1 and Accused No. 3
- 02.01.2019: Attempt to lodge FIR; private complaints filed under Section 156(3) CrPC
- 11.07.2019: Application for sanction filed with Settlement Commissioner and Director of Land Records
- 30.11.2019: District Superintendent of Land Records cancelled Mutation Entry No. 7062
- 17.03.2020: JMFC directed investigation (Criminal Misc. Application No. 323 of 2019)
- 20.03.2020: FIR No. 79 of 2020 registered; arrests made
- 05.08.2020: Respondent No. 1 suspended
- 13.08.2020: Criminal Application No. 1371 of 2020 filed before High Court
- 04.03.2021: JMFC directed investigation (Criminal Misc. Application No. 421 of 2019)
- 06.03.2021: FIR No. 62 of 2021 registered
- 17.12.2021: Criminal Application No. 3235 of 2021 filed before High Court
- 21.12.2023: Chargesheet filed in RCC No. 1020 of 2023
- 12.02.2024: Chargesheet filed in RCC No. 119 of 2024
- 27.11.2024: High Court quashed proceedings in both Criminal Applications
- 17.11.2026: Supreme Court judgment setting aside High Court order
Relief Sought
The appellant sought setting aside of the High Court order dated 27.11.2024, restoration of RCC No. 1020 of 2023 and RCC No. 119 of 2024 to the file of CJM, Dhule, and direction for trial to proceed in accordance with law.
The Legal Issue
The central question was whether the acts complained of - conspiring to prepare forged documents, falsely presenting them as genuine, manipulating property records, and executing mutation entries with intention to cheat - constitute acts done in the discharge of official duties or purported discharge thereof, thereby attracting the protection of Section 197 CrPC read with the Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) CrPC requiring prior sanction for investigation.
Arguments Presented
For the Appellant
Learned Counsel for the appellant contended that the offences committed by Respondent No. 1 cannot be said to be in discharge of official duties or purported discharge thereof. It was no part of the duty of a City Survey Officer to commit forgery or use forged documents. Section 156(3) CrPC as amended in Maharashtra would have no application since the protection applies only to acts committed in discharge of official duty. Even assuming the acts were part of official duty, an application for sanction was made to the competent authority - the Settlement Commissioner and Director of Land Records (Maharashtra State) - and the High Court erred in assuming, based solely on oral statements of counsel for Respondent No. 1, that this authority was not competent.
For the Respondent/State
Mr. Raman Yadav, Learned Counsel for the State of Maharashtra, submitted that Section 197 CrPC would be attracted only where the act complained of bears a reasonable nexus with the discharge of official duties. Acts involving fabrication of records or creation of false documents can never form part of discharge of official powers; therefore, the protection under the relevant sections was not attracted. Referring to the chargesheet allegations, Learned Counsel contended that Respondent No. 1 misused his official position to facilitate fabrication of the mutation application and subsequently altered revenue records.
Mr. Siddharth S. Chapalgaonkar, Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 1, submitted that an application was duly received for mutation and it was only after obtaining the opinion of the District Government Pleader that the mutation was effected. Learned Counsel contended the acts were clearly done in official capacity with proper due diligence, and merely because the order is erroneous, no criminality can be attributed. Reliance was placed on the absence of sanction under Section 156(3) of the Maharashtra Amendment read with Section 197 CrPC.
The Court's Analysis
The Court examined the Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) CrPC (Maharashtra Act 33 of 2016), which provides that no Magistrate shall order investigation against a public servant in respect of acts done while acting or purporting to act in discharge of official duties except with previous sanction under Section 197 CrPC. The second proviso deems sanction accorded if the sanctioning authority fails to decide within ninety days.
The Court relied on the principles summarised by Justice J.B. Pardiwala in Om Prakash Yadav vs. Niranjan Kumar Upadhyay and Others (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3726). The key tests extracted include: (i) the object of Section 197 is to protect honest public servants from vexatious proceedings for acts done in official capacity; (ii) the expression "acting or purporting to act in discharge of official duty" must be construed to strike a balance - strictly limited to acts in "course of duty" but liberally construed once official nature is ascertained; (iii) the act must be integrally connected or directly linked to official duties; (iv) the foremost test is whether the public servant can reasonably claim the act was done in virtue of office; (v) there must be a reasonable connection between the act and official duty, not a pretended or fanciful claim; (vi) excess in performing duty does not deprive protection if reasonable connection exists; (vii) the "quality" of the act must be examined - mere opportunity furnished by official position is insufficient; (viii) "purporting to act" means acts under color of office, but protection must not be limitless; (ix) a safe test is whether omission to commit the act would constitute dereliction of duty; (x) the provision must not be abused to camouflage crimes under color of public office.
Applying these principles, the Court found the case against Respondent No. 1 is one of conspiring to commit criminal offences by preparing forged documents and falsely presenting them as genuine, with the intention to transfer property to Accused No. 1 and 18 others. There are allegations of manipulation of property records and execution of mutation entry with intention to cheat. The chargesheet reveals tampering of the original application, pasting of photograph later, addition of handwritten note "as per the court order" not in original, and submission of forged "List No. 2" which was confirmed destroyed in a 2011 fire. Accused Nos. 2 and 3 approved the mutation without hearing, without verifying documents, and without ensuring documents mentioned were actually submitted.
The Court held: "On the facts of the case, we are convinced that Section 197 read with Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. are not attracted to the facts of the present case." The observations were limited to the aspect of sanction to prosecute; the trial and other proceedings will be conducted independently on their own merits.
The Verdict
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals and set aside the impugned order dated 27.11.2024 passed by the High Court in Criminal Application Nos. 1371 of 2020 and 3235 of 2021. The Court directed that RCC Nos. 1020 of 2023 and 119 of 2024 be restored to the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhule, and shall be proceeded with in accordance with law. No costs were awarded.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Forgery and Fabrication Fall Outside Official Duty Protection
The judgment reinforces that the protection of Section 197 CrPC is not a blanket shield for all acts performed by a public servant during office hours or using official resources. The "quality" of the act is determinative. Where the allegations involve deliberate fabrication of documents, tampering with records, and conspiracy to defraud, the acts are dehors official duties. Practitioners should focus on the specific nature of the alleged act - not the official capacity of the accused - when challenging sanction requirements.
Deemed Sanction Does Not Cure Application to Incompetent Authority
The Maharashtra Amendment's deemed sanction provision (ninety-day timeline) applies only when the application is made to the competent authority - the authority with power to appoint and remove the public servant. The High Court correctly identified that the Settlement Commissioner and Director of Land Records was not the removing authority for a Class-II officer (the State Government was). However, the Supreme Court found it unnecessary to decide this point because Section 197 itself was inapplicable. Practitioners must still identify the correct sanctioning authority ab initio when Section 197 is genuinely attracted.
Chargesheet Allegations Define the Scope of "Official Duty" at Pre-Trial Stage
At the stage of deciding sanction applicability, the Court examines the allegations in the chargesheet and complaint to determine whether the acts, if proven, would fall within official duties. The detailed chargesheet findings - tampered application, forged supporting documents, conspiracy to cheat - were decisive. This underscores the importance of a thorough investigation and precise chargesheet drafting: the factual narrative in the chargesheet frames the legal question of sanction for the court.






