
The Allahabad High Court has set aside an order by the Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Kanpur Nagar, which mechanically converted an application under Section 173(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) into a complaint case without examining the mandatory procedural safeguards applicable to allegations against public servants. The Court held that the Special Judge failed to apply judicial mind to the statutory requirements under Sections 175(3), 175(4), 223(1), and 223(2) BNSS, and issued comprehensive directions for all judicial officers in Uttar Pradesh to ensure compliance with the new procedural regime.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The appellant, Manoj Kumar Paswan, a resident of Chhoti Juhi, Parm Purwa, Kanpur Nagar, filed an application under Section 173(4) BNSS on 9 July 2025 before the Special Judge (Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act), Kanpur Nagar. He alleged that police personnel posted at Police Outpost Parm Purwa had registered a false criminal case against him under Sections 126 and 135 BNSS at Police Station Govind Nagar on 24 February 2025, and had assaulted him and his relative Vijay Bahadur using caste-indicative abuse while he was illegally detained at the outpost.
Key Facts
- 10 February 2025: A confrontation occurred between the appellant's wife, Rita, and their neighbour Shiv Kumar alias Bhediya. The wife alleged Shiv Kumar was taking obscene photographs and singing songs; when she objected, he tried to pull her. She raised an alarm, informed police via dial 112, lodged a complaint on the Chief Minister's portal, and approached Police Outpost Parm Purwa. Shiv Kumar was detained for a few hours and released.
- 14 February 2025: The appellant's wife sent a written complaint by registered post to police authorities alleging assault by Shiv Kumar, Jaydevi, and others. No effective action was taken.
- 24 February 2025 (1:30 pm): Police personnel from Parm Purwa outpost came to the appellant's house, directed him to accompany them to the police station, abused him by referring to his caste, and threatened a relative who objected. The appellant was taken to the outpost and allegedly assaulted with plastic sticks on the soles of his feet and other body parts (25 - 30 blows).
- The police allegedly created a false incident outside the outpost showing a quarrel between the appellant and Shiv Kumar, took photographs, and sent the appellant for medical examination. The appellant alleged a false medical report was prepared omitting internal injuries.
- 25 February 2025: The appellant's wife sent a complaint to the Police Commissioner, Kanpur Nagar, by registered post. The appellant's father submitted a complaint to the Public Grievance Redressal Cell (Jan Sunwai). The appellant himself submitted a complaint to the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Saket Nagar.
- 24 February 2025: The police initiated preventive proceedings against the appellant under Sections 170, 126, and 135 BNSS.
- The police version was that a quarrel had taken place between the appellant and Shiv Kumar, and action was taken under Sections 170, 126, 135 BNSS.
- No criminal case was registered on the basis of the appellant's allegations despite multiple complaints to higher authorities.
Procedural History
- 9 July 2025: The Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Kanpur Nagar, passed the impugned order in Criminal Miscellaneous Case No. 547 of 2025. The Special Judge observed that the allegations related to assault and caste-based abuses by police personnel, but no injury report had been filed. Relying on Naresh Kumar Balmiki v. State of Uttar Pradesh (Criminal Miscellaneous Application under Section 482 CrPC No. 14443 of 2022, decided 17 October 2022) and Sukhwasi v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2008 Cri LJ 472), the Special Judge directed that the application under Section 173(4) BNSS be registered as a complaint case and fixed the matter for 3 September 2025 for recording the complainant's statement under Section 223 BNSS.
- 2025: The appellant filed Criminal Appeal No. 7460 of 2025 before the Allahabad High Court challenging the order.
- 30 October 2026: Appeal reserved for judgment.
- 17 November 2026: Judgment delivered by Hon'ble Justice Santosh Rai.
Relief Sought
The appellant sought setting aside of the impugned order dated 9 July 2025 and a direction to the concerned police authorities to register an FIR against opposite parties 2 to 6 (police personnel) instead of treating the matter as a complaint case.
The Legal Issue
The central questions were: (1) Whether an application under Section 173(4) BNSS can be mechanically converted into a complaint case without examining the statutory requirements for such conversion; (2) Whether the mandatory procedural safeguards under Sections 175(3), 175(4), 223(1), and 223(2) BNSS - particularly those protecting public servants accused of offences arising from discharge of official duties - were complied with; (3) Whether a prima facie case warranting investigation or prosecution was disclosed from the material on record.
Arguments Presented
For the Appellant
The appellant contended that the Special Judge ought to have allowed the application under Section 173(4) BNSS and directed registration of an FIR against the police personnel (opposite parties 2 to 6), as the allegations disclosed cognizable offences requiring proper police investigation. It was submitted that the Special Judge failed to appreciate the allegations and documentary evidence, including the registered postal receipts of complaints sent to higher authorities, and passed the order without considering material facts and circumstances. The appellant argued that the precedents relied upon by the Special Judge (Sukhwasi and Naresh Kumar Balmiki) were decided under the old CrPC regime and could not be applied inflexibly without examining the factual matrix and the new statutory scheme under the BNSS.
For the Respondent
The State, represented by the Additional Government Advocate, supported the impugned order. The State's position was that the police had intervened in a dispute between the appellant and his neighbour and initiated preventive proceedings under Sections 170, 126, 135 BNSS, which indicated bona fide discharge of official duty. The allegations of assault and caste-based abuse were unsubstantiated by reliable medical evidence. The State maintained that the Special Judge correctly exercised discretion in treating the application as a complaint case rather than directing police investigation.
The Court's Analysis
The Court undertook a detailed examination of the statutory scheme under the BNSS. Section 173(4) BNSS provides that a person aggrieved by a police officer's refusal to record information may send the substance in writing to the Superintendent of Police, who, if satisfied that a cognizable offence is disclosed, shall investigate or direct investigation; failing which, the aggrieved person may apply to the Magistrate. Section 175(3) BNSS requires the Magistrate, before ordering investigation, to consider the application supported by an affidavit under Section 173(4), conduct such inquiry as deemed necessary, and consider submissions by the police officer. Section 175(4) BNSS - a new provision with no direct counterpart in the CrPC - adds a special safeguard for public servants: where a complaint against a public servant arises in the course of discharge of official duties, the Magistrate may order investigation only after (a) receiving a report from the officer superior to the accused public servant, and (b) considering the assertions of the public servant regarding the situation leading to the incident.
The Court held that the Special Judge failed to examine whether these statutory conditions were satisfied. The impugned order did not reflect any consideration of the affidavit requirement, inquiry, or police submissions under Section 175(3), nor did it address the special procedure under Section 175(4) despite the allegations being against police personnel acting in their official capacity.
Turning to the complaint procedure, Section 223(1) BNSS mandates that a Magistrate taking cognizance on complaint shall examine the complainant on oath, with a proviso that no cognizance shall be taken without giving the accused an opportunity of being heard. Section 223(2) BNSS further provides that no cognizance shall be taken on a complaint against a public servant for an offence alleged to have been committed in the discharge of official functions unless (a) the public servant is given an opportunity to make assertions, and (b) a report from the superior officer is received. The Supreme Court in Parvinder Singh v. Directorate of Enforcement (2026 SCC OnLine SC 903) held that the first proviso to Section 223(1) is substantive and mandatory, conferring a right to fair trial under Article 21; cognizance taken without compliance is void ab initio.
"The word 'shall' occurring in the said proviso has to be construed to be mandatory in nature, which enures to the benefit of an accused. Resultantly, cognizance of an offence taken by a Court without due compliance of the aforestated proviso would be void ab initio."
The Court found that the Special Judge, having converted the application into a complaint case and fixed it for recording the complainant's statement under Section 223 BNSS, had effectively taken cognizance. However, the order did not disclose that the mandatory opportunity of hearing was afforded to the police personnel (public servants), or that the superior officer's report was obtained under Section 223(2). The Court also noted the absence of any examination of Section 218 BNSS (sanction for prosecution of public servants).
The Court distinguished the precedents relied upon by the Special Judge. Sukhwasi and Naresh Kumar Balmiki were decided under the CrPC, before the BNSS came into force, and could not be treated as laying down an inflexible rule that every Section 173(4) application must be registered as a complaint. The Court emphasized that the choice between directing investigation and proceeding on complaint must be determined on the basis of the nature of allegations, material on record, and applicable statutory provisions.
The Court also considered the factual matrix: the admitted confrontation on 10 February 2025, the preventive proceedings initiated by police on 24 February 2025 under Sections 170, 126, 135 BNSS, and the absence of reliable medical evidence supporting the specific allegation of 25 - 30 blows. These circumstances required due consideration. The apprehension of false implication was not founded on specific material. However, the Court clarified that these factors were relevant only for assessing the material and could not be treated as conclusive proof that no offence was committed.
Relying on Babu Venkatesh v. State of Karnataka (2022) 5 SCC 639, Om Prakash Ambadkar v. State of Maharashtra (2026) 2 SCC 622, Kushal Kumar Agarwal v. Directorate of Enforcement (2025 SCC OnLine SC 1221), State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335, Popular Muthiah v. State (2006) 7 SCC 296, and Ishwar Chand Sharma v. State of U.P. (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1004), the Court reiterated that criminal proceedings cannot be initiated merely on allegations without examining whether essential ingredients of the alleged offences are prima facie disclosed, and that Magistrates must not act as mere forwarding authorities.
The Verdict
The appellant succeeded. The Allahabad High Court set aside the impugned order dated 9 July 2025 passed by the Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Kanpur Nagar, in Criminal Miscellaneous Case No. 547 of 2025. The Court held that neither a prima facie case warranting investigation or prosecution had been demonstrated, nor had the mandatory procedural safeguards applicable to prosecution of public servants been duly considered. Continuation of proceedings would amount to permitting criminal process to operate without adequate legal foundation and in disregard of the procedure established by law.
The Court issued eight general directions for all Magistrates and Special Courts in Uttar Pradesh covering: (i) merit-based examination of Section 173(4) applications with compliance of statutory requirements; (ii) prohibition on automatic conversion to complaint without recorded reasons; (iii) strict adherence to Sections 223 - 227 BNSS when treating applications as complaints, including mandatory opportunity of hearing under the first proviso to Section 223(1) (which may be oral or written), right of proposed accused to receive copies of complaint and annexures, and reasoned judicial orders on legal objections; (iv) independent examination of Section 223(2) applicability for public servants; (v) non-mechanical application of Sections 175(4) and 223(2) based on nature of allegations and connection to official duties; (vi) limiting inquiry under Sections 175(3) and 225 BNSS to determining sufficient grounds, not mini-trials; (vii) careful scrutiny in cases arising from civil, property, financial, or previous litigation disputes to detect mala fide intent; (viii) express recording of cognizance under Section 210(1)(a) BNSS read with Chapter XVI. A copy of the directions was ordered to be circulated to all judicial officers through the Registrar General and the Director, Judicial Training and Research Institute (JTRI), Lucknow.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Mechanical Conversion to Complaint Is Impermissible
A Magistrate cannot automatically convert a Section 173(4) BNSS application into a complaint case merely because it declines to direct police investigation. The Court must record specific reasons for such conversion, keeping in view the nature of allegations and the relief sought. The decision to proceed under the complaint procedure requires independent judicial satisfaction that the allegations and materials disclose the commission of an offence and that statutory conditions for cognizance are fulfilled.
Public Servant Safeguards Are Mandatory, Not Directory
- Section 175(4) BNSS: Before ordering investigation against a public servant for allegations arising from discharge of official duties, the Magistrate must obtain a report from the superior officer and consider the public servant's assertions.
- Section 223(2) BNSS: Before taking cognizance on a complaint against a public servant for offences in discharge of official functions, the Magistrate must afford an opportunity to the public servant to make assertions and obtain the superior officer's report.
- These safeguards apply only when allegations have a reasonable connection with the discharge of official duties - not mechanically because the accused is a public servant.
Opportunity of Hearing Before Cognizance Is a Substantive Right
- The first proviso to Section 223(1) BNSS is mandatory and substantive (per Parvinder Singh). Cognizance taken without affording the accused an opportunity of being heard is void ab initio.
- "Opportunity of being heard" includes written submissions; the proposed accused may place written objections demonstrating absence of jurisdiction, legal bar, limitation, statutory prohibition, or absence of essential ingredients of the alleged offence.
- The Court must consider material legal objections and pass a reasoned order, but must not conduct a mini-trial or roving inquiry at the pre-cognizance stage.
Judicial Mind Must Be Applied at Every Stage
- Magistrates must not act as "mere forwarding authorities" or "post offices" for complainants' allegations.
- Every application under Section 173(4) read with Section 175(3) BNSS must be examined on its own merits with compliance of affidavit requirement, prior approach to SP, and necessity of police investigation.
- In cases arising from civil, property, financial, or previous litigation disputes, the Court must carefully examine whether allegations independently disclose a criminal offence or whether criminal process is being misused with mala fide intent.
Practical Takeaways for Practitioners
- When filing Section 173(4) applications, ensure compliance with the affidavit requirement and prior approach to the Superintendent of Police.
- If the application is converted to a complaint, insist on compliance with Section 223 BNSS safeguards: demand opportunity of hearing (oral or written), supply of complaint and annexures, and a reasoned order on legal objections before cognizance.
- For public servant accused, specifically invoke Sections 175(4) and 223(2) BNSS and Section 218 BNSS (sanction) where allegations arise from official duties.
- Challenge mechanical conversions and non-compliance with statutory safeguards as jurisdictional defects rendering subsequent proceedings void ab initio.






