
The Chhattisgarh High Court has clarified that Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 criminalises sexual intercourse obtained by a promise to marry made without any intention of fulfilment at its inception, not a promise that genuinely existed but was later broken. Setting aside a conviction for five years' rigorous imprisonment, the Court held that a prolonged consensual relationship, cohabitation, a temple ceremony, and the victim's own conduct treating the appellant as her husband collectively negated the inference of a deceitful promise from the outset.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The appellant, Vishnu Prasad Thakur, challenged his conviction and sentence under Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) by the Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Balod in Sessions Trial No. 21/2025. The trial court had sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for five years, a fine of Rs. 2,000, and in default, additional rigorous imprisonment for one month. He was acquitted of charges under Sections 296 and 115(2) of the BNS. The appeal raised the question whether the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant made a promise to marry the victim without any intention of fulfilling it.
Key Facts
- The victim (PW-1), aged about 19 years at the time of the incident, admitted being in a love relationship with the appellant since 2022.
- She accepted the appellant's proposal on 14.02.2022 and remained in a relationship thereafter.
- In 2022, she lodged an FIR against the appellant (Sessions Trial No. 55/2022) alleging sexual exploitation on the pretext of marriage. During that trial, she turned hostile, leading to the appellant's acquittal.
- While the appellant was in jail in connection with the earlier case, the victim visited him. He promised to marry her and asked her to withdraw the case, which she did.
- After the appellant's release, the victim lived with him in a rented accommodation at Bhilai from 08.08.2024 to 01.11.2024 (approximately six months). During this period, she worked as a computer operator while the appellant did labour work.
- The victim's sister (PW-3) deposed that the appellant took the victim to Rajhara Baba Temple on 27.05.2024, filled vermilion in her hair parting, and thereafter they lived together as husband and wife at Bhilai.
- The victim became two months pregnant as a result of the physical relationship.
- On 09.11.2024, the victim submitted an application before the Women's Cell, Balod (Ex.D/2) seeking counselling in relation to her "husband" and describing the appellant as such. She and her mother (PW-2) went to the Women's Cell because they wanted the appellant and the victim to live together.
- The victim alleged that the appellant subsequently refused to marry her, assaulted her, and threatened to circulate obscene photographs.
- Medical examination (PW-5) revealed no external or internal injuries on the victim's body or private parts.
Procedural History
- 10.12.2024: Victim filed written complaint (Ex.P/1) at Police Station Dallirajhara.
- 10.12.2024: FIR registered as Crime No. 340/2024 under Sections 69, 296, and 115(2) of BNS.
- Investigation completed; charge-sheet filed before Judicial Magistrate First Class, Dallirajhara.
- Case committed to Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Balod for trial.
- 20.01.2026: Trial court pronounced judgment of conviction and order of sentence under Section 69 BNS; acquitted under Sections 296 and 115(2) BNS.
- 2026: Criminal Appeal No. 373 of 2026 filed before High Court of Chhattisgarh.
- 22.09.2026: Judgment reserved.
- 17.11.2026: Judgment pronounced and uploaded.
Relief Sought
The appellant sought acquittal of the charge under Section 69 BNS, setting aside the conviction and sentence dated 20.01.2026, and release from custody. The State sought confirmation of the conviction and dismissal of the appeal.
The Legal Issue
The central question was whether the prosecution had established beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant made a promise to marry the victim without any intention of fulfilling it at the inception of the relationship, such that the sexual intercourse was obtained by deceitful means under Section 69 of the BNS, or whether the evidence disclosed a prolonged consensual relationship that subsequently deteriorated.
Arguments Presented
For the Appellant
Learned counsel submitted that the victim admitted a love relationship since 2022, a prior FIR in 2022 where she turned hostile leading to acquittal, and subsequent cohabitation from August to November 2024. She acknowledged a temple ceremony on 27.05.2024 where vermilion was applied, and an application to the Women's Cell describing the appellant as her husband. The relationship was consensual and not founded on a false promise. The subsequent refusal to marry, without proof of dishonest intention at inception, does not attract Section 69 BNS. Reliance was placed on Mahesh Damu Khare v. State of Maharashtra and Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat.
For the Respondent
Learned counsel for the State supported the trial court's judgment, contending that the oral and documentary evidence established the appellant's guilt under Section 69 BNS. The promise to marry was made deceitfully to obtain sexual relations, and the subsequent refusal and assault corroborated the deceitful intent. The appeal was bereft of substance and liable to be dismissed.
The Court's Analysis
The Court examined Section 69 of the BNS, which for the first time creates a specific offence for sexual intercourse by deceitful means, including a promise to marry without intention of fulfilment. The provision requires proof of two alternative ingredients: (i) deceitful means, or (ii) a promise to marry made without any intention of fulfilling it. The sexual intercourse must not amount to rape.
The Court referred to Mahesh Damu Khare v. State of Maharashtra, (2024) 11 SCC 398, where the Supreme Court observed:
"In our view, if a man is accused of having sexual relationship by making a false promise of marriage and if he is to be held criminally liable, any such physical relationship must be traceable directly to the false promise made and not qualified by other circumstances or consideration... Thus, in a situation where physical relationship is maintained for a prolonged period knowingly by the woman, it cannot be said with certainty that the said physical relationship was purely because of the alleged promise made by the appellant to marry her."
The Court also relied on Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat, 2026 INSC 987, which held that there must be adequate material to establish that the accused had no intention whatsoever of fulfilling the promise to marry from the very inception, and that a subsequent failure to marry cannot retrospectively convert a genuine promise into a false one.
Applying this standard, the Court found the prosecution evidence insufficient. The victim's testimony disclosed a relationship since 2022, repeated discussions of marriage, withdrawal of the earlier case on the appellant's promise, cohabitation for six months at Bhilai, the temple ceremony on 27.05.2024, and the victim's own application to the Women's Cell seeking to live with the appellant as her husband. These circumstances indicated a continuing consensual relationship, not one induced by a promise that was false from its inception.
The Court noted material omissions in the evidence of PW-2 and PW-3: the Investigating Officer (PW-10) admitted that the victim's mother and sister had not stated in their police statements several material facts later introduced in court, including the appellant's alleged postponement of marriage at Bhilai, assault, and abandonment. The medical evidence showed no injuries, and the pregnancy/DNA evidence did not establish the appellant's mental state at the time of the alleged promise.
The Court emphasized that the victim's conduct after the alleged promise - continued cohabitation, treating the appellant as husband, seeking reconciliation through the Women's Cell - was difficult to reconcile with the theory of a deceitful promise from the beginning. The subsequent deterioration of the relationship and refusal to marry, without more, could not establish the essential ingredient of deceitful intention at inception.
The Court reiterated the principle that where two views are reasonably possible on the evidence, the view favourable to the accused must be adopted. Suspicion, however strong, cannot substitute proof beyond reasonable doubt.
The Verdict
The appeal was allowed. The impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 20.01.2026 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Balod in Sessions Trial No. 21/2025, convicting and sentencing the appellant under Section 69 BNS, was set aside. The appellant was acquitted of the charge under Section 69 BNS by extending the benefit of doubt. The appellant, reported to be in jail, was directed to be set at liberty forthwith if not required in any other case. The fine amount, if deposited, was ordered to be refunded. Pursuant to Section 481 of the BNSS, 2023, the appellant was directed to furnish a personal bond of Rs. 25,000 with one surety in the like amount before the concerned court, effective for six months, with an undertaking to appear before the Supreme Court if a special leave petition is filed.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Deceitful Intent Must Exist at Inception
The judgment reinforces that Section 69 BNS targets only those promises to marry that are false when made, not promises that are genuine but later unfulfilled. Practitioners must focus on the accused's state of mind at the inception of the relationship. Evidence of subsequent conduct - cohabitation, marriage ceremonies, the victim's own treatment of the accused as a spouse - is highly relevant to rebut the inference of a deceitful promise from the outset.
Prolonged Consensual Relationship Weakens Prosecution Case
- A relationship spanning years, with repeated discussions of marriage and mutual cohabitation, makes it difficult to prove that the sexual relationship was solely induced by a false promise.
- The victim's own actions (withdrawing a prior case on promise of marriage, living together for months, approaching a Women's Cell for reconciliation) constitute contemporaneous circumstances that contradict the theory of a deceitful inducement.
- Courts will scrutinize whether the physical relationship is "traceable directly to the false promise" or influenced by other considerations such as personal affection.
Material Omissions in Witness Statements Are Fatal
- The Investigating Officer's admission that key allegations (assault, postponement of marriage, abandonment) were absent from the police statements of the victim's mother and sister severely undermined the prosecution's case.
- Practitioners should meticulously compare police statements under Section 183 BNSS with court depositions to identify material improvements or omissions.
- Medical evidence showing absence of injuries, while not determinative, removes independent corroboration of forcible sexual acts.
Benefit of Doubt Applies Where Two Views Are Possible
The Court's application of the principle that the view favourable to the accused must prevail where evidence admits of two reasonable interpretations provides a clear template for defence arguments in Section 69 cases. The mere fact of a failed relationship, pregnancy, or subsequent refusal to marry does not, without proof of pre-existing dishonest intention, satisfy the statutory standard.






