
The Madras High Court dismissed a civil revision petition filed by Bank of India challenging a trial court order that allowed a suit for damages and interest by a successful auction purchaser under the SARFAESI Act. The Court held that claims for compensation falling outside the Debts Recovery Tribunal's jurisdiction are maintainable before civil courts, following the Supreme Court's precedent in Leelamma Mathew v. Indian Overseas Bank.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The respondent, Mohamed Najumudeen, participated in an e-auction conducted by the petitioner, Bank of India, under the provisions of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act). The respondent was declared the successful bidder for the auctioned property. Pursuant to the auction, he paid a sum of Rs. 1,26,25,000/- to the Bank. The Bank issued a confirmation letter acknowledging the respondent as the successful bidder and confirming receipt of the amount. The Bank also instructed the respondent to deposit the balance sale consideration. Accordingly, the respondent, by his letter dated 20.03.2017, requested the Bank to debit the balance amount of Rs. 3,78,75,000/- from his NRO/NRE account. Despite receipt of the entire sale consideration of Rs. 5,05,00,000/-, the petitioner Bank failed to hand over physical possession of the auction property to the respondent for various reasons. Consequently, the respondent issued a legal notice calling upon the Bank either to hand over physical possession of the property or to cancel the auction and refund the amount paid by him, together with interest. Thereafter, the petitioner Bank refunded the entire amount paid by the respondent but failed to pay the interest claimed by him. Hence, the respondent instituted the suit claiming damages and interest at the rate of 18% per annum, alleging that the failure of the petitioner Bank to hand over possession caused considerable loss and hardship to him.
Key Facts
- The respondent, Mohamed Najumudeen, participated in an e-auction conducted by Bank of India under the SARFAESI Act
- He was declared the successful bidder for the auctioned property
- Total sale consideration: Rs. 5,05,00,000/-
- Initial payment: Rs. 1,26,25,000/-
- Balance payment: Rs. 3,78,75,000/- requested to be debited from NRO/NRE account by letter dated 20.03.2017
- Bank issued confirmation letter acknowledging respondent as successful bidder
- Bank failed to hand over physical possession despite full payment
- Respondent issued legal notice demanding possession or refund with interest at 18% per annum
- Bank refunded principal amount but not interest
- Respondent filed suit (OS No. 3576 of 2020) claiming damages and interest at 18% per annum
Procedural History
- 2020: Original Suit (OS No. 3576 of 2020) filed by respondent before the 23rd Additional City Civil Court, Allikulam, Chennai
- 2023: Bank filed application under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC (IA No. 6 of 2023) seeking rejection of plaint
- 18.08.2023: Trial Court passed order rejecting the Bank's application
- 2023: Bank filed Civil Revision Petition (CRP No. 3815 of 2023) under Article 227 of the Constitution before the Madras High Court
- 23.09.2026: Matter reserved for judgment
- 13.11.2026: Judgment pronounced dismissing the Civil Revision Petition
- Connected Miscellaneous Petition (CMP No. 23646 of 2023) closed
Relief Sought
The petitioner Bank sought to set aside the order dated 18.08.2023 passed by the Trial Court in IA No. 6 of 2023 in OS No. 3576 of 2020. The respondent sought to maintain his suit for damages and interest at 18% per annum for the Bank's failure to deliver possession despite receipt of the full sale consideration of Rs. 5,05,00,000/-.
The Legal Issue
The central question was whether a civil suit for damages and interest by a successful auction purchaser under the SARFAESI Act, where the bank has refunded the sale consideration but failed to deliver possession, is maintainable before a civil court or lies exclusively before the Debts Recovery Tribunal under Section 17(1) of the SARFAESI Act.
Arguments Presented
For the Petitioner
The learned counsel for the petitioner Bank contended that the entire transaction arose out of proceedings initiated under the SARFAESI Act and therefore any grievance could be agitated only before the Debts Recovery Tribunal under Section 17(1) of the SARFAESI Act. It was further submitted that the respondent, having participated in the auction proceedings conducted under the SARFAESI Act, could not claim interest and damages arising out of the said proceedings. The Bank relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Agarwal Tracom Pvt. Ltd. v. Punjab National Bank and Others (2007 INSC 1146), particularly paragraphs 18, 19, 29 and 30, to argue that measures taken under Section 13(4) read with Rule 9 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002, including actions relating to auction purchasers, fall within the purview of Section 17(1). Additional contentions included lack of pecuniary jurisdiction of the Trial Court (bid amount Rs. 5,05,00,000/-), delay attributable to non-vacation by occupants and judicial proceedings, and misjoinder of parties (only the fourth petitioner being concerned with SARFAESI proceedings).
For the Respondent
The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the respondent had paid the entire sale consideration as instructed by the Bank with the expectation that physical possession would be handed over. Despite receipt of the entire sale consideration, the Bank failed to fulfil its obligation. The claim for interest and damages is independent of the measures taken under the SARFAESI Act and therefore not barred by Section 34 of the SARFAESI Act. Counsel relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Leelamma Mathew v. Indian Overseas Bank and Others (2022 SCC OnLine SC 1601), where it was held that Section 34 applies only where the DRT is empowered to decide the matter under the SARFAESI Act, and a suit for damages/compensation falling outside DRT jurisdiction is not barred. Counsel also relied on the Madras High Court's own order in CRP No. 3148 of 2025 dated 03.07.2026, which followed Leelamma Mathew to hold that a civil suit claiming damages or compensation outside the purview of DRT jurisdiction is maintainable.
The Court's Analysis
The Court examined the competing precedents. It first considered the Supreme Court's decision in Leelamma Mathew, quoting paragraph 25:
"Section 34 of the SARFAESI Act shall be applicable only in a case where the Debt Recovery Tribunal and / or Appellate Tribunal is empowered to decide the matter under the SARFAESI Act. The plaintiff was not challenging the sale / sale certificate. The plaintiff claimed the damages / compensation with respect to the less area. Therefore, the High Court has seriously erred in holding that the suit was barred by Section 34 of the SARFAESI Act."
The Court noted that this principle had been followed by the Madras High Court in CRP No. 3148 of 2025 dated 03.07.2026. Turning to Agarwal Tracom, the Court observed that the short question in that case was whether the remedy of an auction purchaser aggrieved by forfeiture of deposit lay under Section 17(1) before the DRT or by way of writ petition. The Supreme Court in Agarwal Tracom held that Rule 9(5) confers express power on the secured creditor to forfeit the deposit in case of default by the auction purchaser, and such action is a measure under Section 13(4) read with Rule 9(5), therefore challengeable only under Section 17(1).
The Court distinguished the present case: here, the respondent / plaintiff made a claim for interest on delayed repayment and damages, not a challenge to forfeiture of deposit. The respondent had paid the full sale consideration and the Bank had failed to deliver possession. In view of Leelamma Mathew, the Court held that the claim for damages and compensation falls outside the purview of the SARFAESI Act. As regards the Bank's contentions on delay attribution and misjoinder of parties, the Court found these to involve disputed questions of fact requiring consideration of oral and documentary evidence, which cannot be determined in a revision petition.
The Verdict
The Civil Revision Petition was dismissed. The order dated 18.08.2023 of the 23rd Additional City Civil Judge, Allikulam, Chennai in IA No. 6 of 2023 in OS No. 3576 of 2020 was upheld. The respondent's suit for damages and interest at 18% per annum on the sale consideration of Rs. 5,05,00,000/- (paid via Rs. 1,26,25,000/- initially and Rs. 3,78,75,000/- by letter dated 20.03.2017) shall proceed before the Trial Court. No order as to costs. The connected miscellaneous petition (CMP No. 23646 of 2023) was closed.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Civil Court Jurisdiction For Compensation Claims Upheld
Practitioners representing auction purchasers under the SARFAESI Act can now confidently advise that claims for damages and interest arising from a bank's failure to deliver possession after full payment are maintainable before civil courts. The Leelamma Mathew principle establishes that Section 34 of the SARFAESI Act does not bar suits where the relief sought falls outside the jurisdiction of the Debts Recovery Tribunal. This creates a clear jurisdictional boundary: challenges to measures under Section 13(4) go to the DRT; independent claims for compensation go to civil courts.
Distinction Between Forfeiture And Non-Delivery Claims Critical
The Court's distinction of Agarwal Tracom is pivotal. Where an auction purchaser defaults and faces forfeiture under Rule 9(5), the remedy lies exclusively under Section 17(1) before the DRT. However, where the purchaser has fully performed and the bank fails to deliver possession, the resulting claim for damages and interest is a separate cause of action outside the SARFAESI framework. Lawyers must carefully frame pleadings to emphasize this distinction.
Factual Disputes Not Resolvable In Revision
- Questions of whether delay was attributable to the bank or to occupants/judicial proceedings require evidence
- Misjoinder of parties must be examined with reference to pleadings and evidence
- Revision courts under Article 227 will not adjudicate such factual controversies
Practical Takeaways
- Auction purchasers should issue legal notices demanding possession or refund with interest promptly upon default
- Civil suits for damages and interest at contractual or reasonable rates (here 18% claimed) are viable
- Banks refunding principal cannot avoid liability for compensation for delay
- Joinder of multiple bank officials/entities as defendants may survive preliminary challenge






