
The Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has held that a Written Statement tendered on the first working day after the statutory 45-day period expires on a public holiday is timely under Section 38(3)(a) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, particularly when the delay in deciding the extension application was attributable to the Commission's own roster constraints. The Commission set aside a District Commission order that had refused to take the insurer's defence on record in a marine cargo claim involving allegations of arson, imposing compensatory costs of Rs. 3,000.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The respondent, M/s. Popular Traders, a partnership firm operating from Dombivli East, had obtained a Marine Cargo Specific Voyage Policy from the petitioner, The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. The policy covered goods in transit. On 24 January 2022, a truck carrying the insured cargo caught fire. Based on an investigation report that alleged deliberate arson after removal of the cargo, the insurer repudiated the claim on 28 November 2022. Aggrieved, the respondent filed Consumer Complaint No. 181 of 2023 before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Thane.
Key Facts
- 24/01/2022: Truck fire incident involving insured cargo
- 28/11/2022: Petitioner repudiated the claim based on investigation report alleging deliberate arson after cargo removal
- 23/06/2023: Notice along with complaint compilation served on the petitioners at both their offices (DO-112500, Fort, Mumbai and B-201, Pinak Galaxy, Thane)
- 22/07/2023: Initial 30-day period for filing Written Statement expired (Saturday)
- 23/07/2023: Sunday
- 25/07/2023: Petitioners appeared through advocate, filed Vakalatnama, and moved application for 15-day extension under Section 38(3)(a) citing time required for document procurement; matter deferred to 07/08/2023 as In-charge President was presiding over another Commission
- 06/08/2023: Outer statutory limit of 45 days (30 + 15) expired (Sunday)
- 07/08/2023: Petitioners tendered Written Statement on the next working day (Monday); application for extension still pending adjudication as Bench was busy with judgments and auto-adjourned the board; Written Statement acknowledged on certified copy but inadvertently omitted from daily Roznama
- 18/10/2023: Due to advocate's diary error (noted as 18/11/2023), petitioners' advocate absent; District Commission passed impugned order rejecting prayer to take Written Statement on record
Procedural History
- 23/06/2023: Service of notice and complaint compilation on petitioners
- 25/07/2023: First hearing; petitioners appear, file Vakalatnama, move extension application; matter adjourned to 07/08/2023
- 07/08/2023: Petitioners tender Written Statement; Bench auto-adjourns to 18/10/2023 due to judgment pronouncements
- 18/10/2023: Impugned order passed by District Commission, Thane in CC/181/2023 rejecting petitioners' prayer to take Written Statement on record
- 2024: Revision Petition No. SC/27/RP/18/2024 filed before State Commission under Section 47(1)(b) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
- 16/11/2026: Judgment delivered by State Commission
Relief Sought
The petitioners sought quashing of the District Commission's order dated 18/10/2023, allowance of their extension application under Section 38(3)(a), direction to take their Written Statement (tendered on 07/08/2023) on record, and remand for adjudication on merits.
The Legal Issue
The central question was whether the District Commission committed a material irregularity by refusing to take the Written Statement on record when it was tendered on 07/08/2023 - the first working day after the 45-day statutory ceiling expired on a Sunday - while the extension application filed within the 45-day window remained undecided solely due to the Commission's own preoccupation.
Arguments Presented
For the Petitioner
Advocate Asim Vidyarthi submitted that the 30-day period expired on 22/07/2023 (Saturday). The extension application was filed on 25/07/2023, well within the extendable 15-day window. The outer limit of 45 days fell on 06/08/2023 (Sunday), a public holiday. By virtue of Section 10 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, the act of filing on the next working day (07/08/2023) was timely. The delay in deciding the extension application was attributable to the Bench's non-availability on 25/07/2023 and its preoccupation with judgments on 07/08/2023, not to the petitioners. The Written Statement was tendered on the 45th effective working day. Refusing to take it on record in a case involving serious allegations of fraud and arson resulted in a miscarriage of justice.
For the Respondent
Advocate Rupam Ghosh contended that the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 mandates speedy disposal and does not permit casual adjournments. The petitioners, a prominent public-sector insurer with full legal infrastructure, failed to show "sufficient cause" for not filing within the initial 30 days. The extension application was presented across the bar without prior service on the respondent on 25/07/2023. On 07/08/2023, the Commission auto-adjourned the matter; any filing behind the respondent's back without an express order granting extension is void. Reliance was placed on Babu Ram vs. Sartaj Ali (NCDRC, Revision Petition No. 3493 of 2017, decided 01/05/2024) and Rubi (Chandra) Dutta vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2011) 11 SCC 269] to argue that revisional jurisdiction under Section 47(1)(b) is extremely limited and cannot interfere with a reasoned discretionary order absent jurisdictional error or material irregularity.
The Court's Analysis
The Commission, per Dr. Nisha Amol Chavhan, Member, examined the statutory framework under Section 38(3)(a) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which mandates that the Opposite Party file its version within 30 days, extendable by a further period not exceeding 15 days. The Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. vs. Hilli Multipurpose Cold Storage Pvt. Ltd. [(2020) 5 SCC 757] had settled that the outer limit of 45 days is mandatory and cannot be extended by any Consumer Commission.
"Computing the timeline from the date of receipt. The initial 30 days expired on 22/07/2023 (Saturday). The Petitioners appeared on 25/07/2023 (within the extendable 15-day window) and formally applied for the 15-day extension. The outer limit of 45 days from 23/06/2023 expired on 06/08/2023, which indisputably fell on a Sunday (a public holiday). By virtue of Section 10 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, when the last day of a prescribed period falls on a day when the court/office is closed, the act is considered done in due time if performed on the next day afterwards on which the commission is open namely, Monday, 07/08/2023."
The Commission found that the extension application, filed on 25/07/2023, remained pending adjudication on 07/08/2023 because the Bench could not take up the matter on 25/07/2023 (In-charge President absent) and again on 07/08/2023 (Bench busy with judgments). Thus, the delay was attributable to the Commission's own roster constraints, not the petitioners. The Written Statement was tendered on 07/08/2023 - the 45th effective working day.
Addressing Babu Ram vs. Sartaj Ali, the Commission acknowledged that revisional jurisdiction under Section 47(1)(b) is narrow, meant to correct jurisdictional errors or material irregularities, as reiterated in Rubi (Chandra) Dutta and Sunil Kumar Maity vs. SBI. However, the present case squarely attracted revisional interference because the District Commission failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in it by law. When an extension application is filed within the 45-day window and remains undecided solely due to the Commission's own adjournment, and the Written Statement is tendered on the 45th working day, shutting out the substantive defence - especially in a dispute involving serious allegations of fraud and arson - results in a miscarriage of justice and constitutes a material irregularity.
The Commission also noted the respondent's inconvenience due to the petitioners' failure to serve an advance copy of the extension application and their non-appearance on 18/10/2023. This was adequately addressed by imposing compensatory costs.
The Verdict
The Revision Petition was allowed subject to payment of costs of Rs. 3,000/- to the respondent. The impugned order dated 18/10/2023 passed by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Thane in Consumer Complaint No. 181 of 2023 was quashed and set aside. The petitioners' application for 15-day extension under Section 38(3)(a) was allowed, and the Written Statement tendered on 07/08/2023 was directed to be taken on record by the District Commission within 15 days from receipt of the order. The District Commission was directed to adjudicate the complaint on merits after affording the complainant an opportunity to file a Rejoinder/Additional Affidavit of Evidence. Both parties were directed to appear before the District Commission on 16/12/2026.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Bench Delay Does Not Prejudice Parties
When a statutory deadline expires on a court holiday, Section 10 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 extends compliance to the next working day. If an extension application is filed within the prescribed window and remains undecided due to the forum's own roster constraints, a party's tender of the Written Statement on the extended deadline (as extended by Section 10) is timely. Practitioners should:
- File extension applications promptly within the 45-day window
- Ensure Written Statements are tendered on the first working day after a holiday deadline
- Place on record the cause list and Roznama entries showing Bench preoccupation
Revisional Jurisdiction Covers Failure to Exercise Vested Jurisdiction
The narrow revisional jurisdiction under Section 47(1)(b) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 encompasses situations where a District Commission fails to exercise jurisdiction legally vested in it. A refusal to consider a Written Statement tendered within the effective statutory period - due to the Commission's own delay in deciding a pending extension application - constitutes a material irregularity warranting interference. This is especially so when serious allegations (fraud, arson) require a full trial on merits.
Compensatory Costs Balance Equities
Courts may impose compensatory costs on a party whose procedural lapses (failure to serve advance copy, advocate's diary error, non-appearance) caused inconvenience to the opposite side, while still granting substantive relief. This ensures that technical defaults do not override the mandate for adjudication on merits under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.






