#CPC Order 41 Rule 27

MP High Court rules that original permanent disability certificates filed under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC must be physically returned to the Claims Tribunal to ensure proper adjudication. Failure to do so violates evidentiary fairness, as medical opinions cannot be formed without examining the original document. The ruling sets a binding precedent for appellate courts handling similar evidence under the Motor Vehicles Act.

Punjab & Haryana HC ruled that Income Tax Returns can be admitted as additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC to rectify speculative income assessments in motor accident claims, ensuring just compensation. The decision underscores that appellate courts may permit crucial evidence even if not produced earlier, if it materially impacts the case outcome.

HP High Court reinforces that appellate courts cannot permit additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC unless the party demonstrates strict due diligence and consistency in pleadings. The ruling underscores that 'complete justice' cannot override statutory conditions, impacting litigants seeking to introduce new evidence post-delay.