Topic

Caste Scrutiny Committee

2 articlesLatest July 2026
Pre-constitutional Caste Records Valid Despite Spelling Variations | Warthi vs Watthi Dispute Upheld: Bombay HC (Nagpur Bench)
Case Law Analysis
|Bombay High Court

Pre-constitutional Caste Records Valid Despite Spelling Variations | Warthi vs Watthi Dispute Upheld: Bombay HC (Nagpur Bench)

The Bombay High Court has ruled that minor spelling discrepancies in pre-constitutional documents-such as 'Watthi' versus 'Warthi'-do not invalidate caste claims when genealogical continuity and official records support identity. This sets a critical precedent for OBC certificate applicants relying on colonial-era records, reinforcing that procedural technicalities cannot override substantive historical evidence under natural justice.

Valid Caste Certificate Triggers Mandatory Scrutiny for School Record Correction | Natural Justice Violated by Refusal : CGHC
Case Law Analysis
|Chhattisgarh High Court

Valid Caste Certificate Triggers Mandatory Scrutiny for School Record Correction | Natural Justice Violated by Refusal : CGHC

The Chhattisgarh High Court ruled that when a minor produces a valid caste certificate, authorities must refer the claim to the District Committee for scrutiny - refusing to do so violates natural justice and deprives children of their future reservation rights. This sets a binding precedent for all educational institutions to act on certified caste claims, not dismiss them on procedural grounds.