
The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has set aside a State Commission award of Rs 40 lakh for medical negligence against a gastroenterologist and his hospital, finding that the treating specialist followed accepted medical protocol for acute alcoholic pancreatitis. The Commission held the hospital liable for Rs 5 lakh for deploying BAMS-qualified doctors to supervise a critical ICU patient in the specialist's absence, violating MCI regulations and NABH accreditation standards.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The appellants, Liver and Digestive Diseases Centre, Amritsar (OP-1) and Dr Harpreet Singh (OP-2), challenged the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Punjab order dated 27.10.2020 in CC No. 354/2018. The State Commission had held both appellants liable for deficiency in service and medical negligence in treating Iqbal Singh, who died on 09.08.2017 at Fortis Escorts Hospital after being transferred from OP-1. The complainant, Loveleen Kaur (wife of the deceased), sought compensation of Rs 40 lakh along with refund of medical bills.
Key Facts
- Iqbal Singh, aged about 33 years, was transferred from Beas Charitable Hospital to Liver and Digestive Diseases Centre on 02.08.2017 with diagnosis of acute pancreatitis, history of heavy alcohol consumption for two years, seizure disorder for three years, and on medication (paroxetine and pregabalin)
- At admission, investigations showed: TLC 17,600, serum amylase 2,871 IU/L (normal 25-115), creatinine 5.8 mg/dL (normal 0.9-1.3), urea 63 mg/dL, BP 80/60 mmHg
- CT scan on 03.08.2017 revealed subacute interstitial edematous pancreatitis with peripancreatic fluid collections, bilateral pleural effusion, basal atelectasis, Grade E severity index 6-7 (carrying 17% mortality per medical literature)
- Patient was managed in ICU with IV fluids, central line, antibiotics, analgesics, sodium bicarbonate; showed improvement by 04.08.2017 (creatinine 1.6, urea 99, amylase 487, TLC 9,500)
- On 04.08.2017 evening, patient's father insisted on shifting from ICU to room despite medical advice; signed handwritten consent in Punjabi accepting responsibility
- Dr Harpreet Singh attended a medical conference in Delhi on 05.08.2017 (departed 6:45 AM flight, returned 06.08.2017 6:20 PM flight)
- During his absence, Dr Manmeet Singh (DM Nephrology) examined patient on 05.08.2017 at 9:40 AM, reviewed vitals, ordered investigations, and directed continuation of treatment; remained in touch with Dr Harpreet Singh
- Two BAMS doctors (Dr Chandani Thakur and Dr Avdesh Kumar) were on duty for patient coordination
- On 06.08.2017 evening, Dr Harpreet Singh returned, found patient unstable with rising TLC (15,900) and bilirubin (2.16), shifted patient to ICU, started antifungals and metrogyl
- On 07.08.2017, patient deteriorated further (TLC 19,500, bilirubin 4.3, BP falling to 80/50), started on norepinephrine and non-invasive ventilation
- 08.08.2017 8:00 AM: Patient transferred to Fortis Escorts Hospital for advanced ventilatory support
- 09.08.2017: Patient expired; death certificate recorded sepsis-septic shock, acute kidney injury, acute edematous pancreatitis, seizure disorder
- Medical Board constituted by Civil Surgeon, Amritsar submitted report on 03.04.2018 finding treatment followed standard protocols; noted Dr Manmeet Singh (DM Nephrology) treated patient in Dr Harpreet Singh's absence; concluded allegation of medical negligence not found directly
- Expert affidavit of Dr Gurbilas P Singh (Consultant Gastroenterologist, Fortis Escorts) affirmed treatment at OP-1 was on same lines as Fortis, no negligence or deficiency
Procedural History
- 04.10.2017: Complaint filed by Sarabjit Singh (father of deceased) with Commissioner of Police
- 02.11.2017: Civil Surgeon letter constituting Medical Board
- 03.04.2018: Medical Board report submitted
- 02.05.2018: Consumer complaint filed before State Commission (CC No. 354/2018)
- 27.10.2020: State Commission allowed complaint, awarded Rs 40,00,000 compensation with 7% interest from 02.05.2018 and Rs 33,000 litigation costs; liability of insurance company as per policy terms (limit Rs 10,00,000)
- FA No. 04 of 2021: First Appeal filed before NCDRC
- 13.11.2026: NCDRC judgment pronounced
Relief Sought
Appellants sought setting aside of State Commission order. Respondent sought dismissal of appeal and confirmation of Rs 40 lakh award with interest and costs.
The Legal Issue
The central questions were: (1) Whether the treatment provided by Dr Harpreet Singh and the hospital from 02.08.2017 to 08.08.2017 constituted medical negligence or deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act; (2) Whether the absence of the treating specialist for a conference, with patient care delegated to a DM Nephrologist and BAMS doctors, amounted to negligence; (3) Whether the State Commission's finding of negligence based on rising TLC levels and the specialist's absence was legally sustainable.
Arguments Presented
For the Appellant
Counsel contended that the patient presented with critical multi-organ involvement from alcoholic pancreatitis (Grade E, severity index 6-7, 17% mortality). Treatment followed established protocol: fluid replacement, pain management, bowel rest, nutritional support, antibiotics. Parameters improved significantly by 04.08.2017. Shift to room was on attendant's written consent. Dr Harpreet Singh's one-day conference attendance was mandated by MCI for professional updating. During absence, Dr Manmeet Singh (DM Nephrology) provided specialist care and remained in communication. No BAMS doctor prescribed allopathic treatment. Medical Board and Fortis expert affirmed protocol compliance. Overwriting of date 04.08.2017 to 05.08.2017 in records was clerical; treatment continuity evidenced by timed entries. State Commission erred in equating BAMS presence with cross-pathy negligence without evidence of allopathic prescription.
For the Respondent
Counsel argued that leaving a critically ill patient (Grade E pancreatitis, 17% mortality) for two days under BAMS doctors violated MCI Regulation 7.10 prohibiting allopathic practitioners from delegating allopathic care to non-allopathic practitioners. Continuous specialist monitoring was imperative. Rising TLC, bilirubin, and clinical deterioration on 05-06.08.2017 demonstrated negligence. Delegation of ICU care to Ayurvedic doctors without patient consent constituted deficiency. Reliance placed on Samira Kohli v. Dr Prabha Manchanda (2008) 2 SCC 1 and Savia Garg v. Director, National Heart Institute 2005 (1) Civil J 621. Overwriting in records suggested fabrication. State Commission's inference of negligence from preponderance of probability was correct and not perverse.
The Court's Analysis
The Commission reiterated the Bolam test as adopted in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005) 6 SCC 1: a doctor is not negligent if acting in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical opinion. The standard is that of an ordinary competent practitioner, not the highest expertise. An error of judgment or choice between reasonable treatment alternatives is not negligence. The standard of care is judged at the time of incident, not at trial.
"A medical practitioner would be held liable only where his conduct fell below that of the standards of a reasonably competent practitioner in his field."
Applying Kusum Sharma v. Batra Hospital (2010) 3 SCC 480 principles reiterated in M.A. Biviji v. Sunita (2024) 2 SCC 242, the Commission examined whether Dr Harpreet Singh lacked requisite skill or failed to exercise reasonable competence. The comparative laboratory table showed: TLC reduced from 17,000 to 6,000 (03.08), 9,500 (04.08); creatinine from 5.8 to 4.7 (03.08) to 1.6 (04.08); amylase from 2,871 to 1,115 (03.08) to 487 (04.08). Patient was stable till 06.08.2017 evening when sudden deterioration occurred due to sepsis/septic shock - a known complication of severe pancreatitis.
The Commission found no evidence that treatment on 05.08.2017 and 06.08.2017 (before Dr Harpreet Singh's return) deviated from protocol. Dr Manmeet Singh (DM Nephrology) examined the patient, reviewed vitals, ordered investigations, and directed treatment continuation. The Medical Board report confirmed: "in the absence of Dr Harpreet Singh, Dr Manmeet Singh Jhavar (he is also a D.M. Nephrology Doctor) treated the patient. As such the allegation of the complainant for medical negligence has not been found directly."
Regarding BAMS doctors: Regulation 7.10 of MCI (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 prohibits allopathic practitioners from appointing Ayurveda practitioners for allopathic services. NABH Accreditation Rules also emphasize qualified specialist availability. The hospital engaged BAMS doctors for indoor management during Dr Harpreet Singh's absence. Though they did not prescribe allopathic treatment, deployment of a qualified allopathic practitioner was imperative for a critical ICU patient. The hospital failed in this duty.
"OP-1 Hospital apparently failed to deliver the expected level of services by way of supervision and monitoring through qualified Allopathic practitioner on 05th and 06th of August, 2017. Considering the afore-said irregularity, we deem it appropriate to award compensation of Rs. 5 lakhs to the Complainant payable by OP-1 Hospital along with litigation expenses of Rs.50,000/-"
The Commission distinguished Savita Garg v. Director, National Heart Institute (2004) 8 SCC 56 on hospital liability, noting that while hospitals are responsible for nursing and paramedical staff, medical services in smaller centres are limited compared to full-fledged facilities. However, the duty to ensure qualified specialist cover during a treating doctor's absence remains.
The Verdict
The appeal was allowed in part. The State Commission order dated 27.10.2020 was set aside. No medical negligence or deficiency in service was attributed to Dr Harpreet Singh (OP-2). The Liver and Digestive Diseases Centre (OP-1) was held liable for Rs 5,00,000 (five lakh) compensation and Rs 50,000 litigation costs, payable within four weeks. Default attracts 9% per annum interest. The insurance company's liability remains as per policy terms (limit Rs 10,00,000).
What This Means For Similar Cases
Specialist Absence Does Not Equal Negligence If Qualified Cover Exists
The judgment clarifies that a treating specialist's temporary absence for mandatory professional development (MCI-mandated conferences) does not constitute negligence if a qualified specialist of appropriate super-specialty (here, DM Nephrology for renal complications of pancreatitis) assumes direct patient care, documents examination, reviews investigations, and maintains communication with the primary consultant. Practitioners must ensure: (a) the covering doctor holds requisite super-specialty qualification for the patient's complications; (b) contemporaneous records reflect direct examination, clinical decisions, and communication with the primary consultant; (c) the covering doctor's affidavit and Medical Board validation are secured.
Hospital Liability For Paramedical Staffing Is Distinct From Doctor Negligence
Hospitals bear independent liability for nursing and paramedical staffing standards. Deployment of BAMS/Ayurveda doctors for ICU monitoring of critically ill allopathic patients violates MCI Regulation 7.10 and NABH norms, attracting compensation even absent proof of specific negligent acts by those staff. The Rs 5 lakh award here was for systemic failure - not for the BAMS doctors' clinical decisions (none proven) but for the hospital's failure to ensure a qualified allopathic practitioner's physical presence for ICU supervision. Hospitals must: (a) maintain 24/7 allopathic specialist cover for critical care units; (b) document handover protocols when primary consultant is unavailable; (c) avoid using non-allopathic practitioners for independent clinical decision-making in allopathic settings.
Documentary Evidence And Expert Validation Trump Inferential Findings
The Commission rejected the State Commission's inference of negligence from rising TLC/bilirubin on 06-07.08.2017, noting these reflected the natural history of severe alcoholic pancreatitis (sepsis, multi-organ dysfunction) not treatment failure. Key takeaway: In medical negligence consumer complaints, the complainant must lead expert evidence establishing deviation from accepted protocol. Absent such evidence, courts will not infer negligence from adverse outcomes alone. The Medical Board report (constituted under criminal complaint) and the receiving hospital expert's affidavit were decisive. Practitioners should: (a) secure independent expert validation of protocol compliance early; (b) ensure Medical Board / institutional inquiry reports are placed on record; (c) challenge inferential findings lacking expert contradiction.
Overwriting In Records Is Not Fatal If Continuity Is Proven
The alleged date overwriting (04.08.2017 to 05.08.2017) was disregarded because treatment entries ran in continuous timed sequence (9:40 AM examination, 11:00 AM and 1:00 PM monitoring). Practical tip: Hospitals should implement tamper-proof electronic medical records or sequential page numbering with timed entries to preempt such allegations. Where manual records exist, any correction must follow standard protocol: single strikethrough, initial, date, reason - never obliteration.






