Topic

mixed question of law and fact

3 articlesLatest March 2026
Order VII Rule 11 CPC | Limitation as Mixed Question of Law and Fact Cannot Be Decided on Pleadings Alone: Allahabad HC
Case Law Analysis
|Allahabad High Court

Order VII Rule 11 CPC | Limitation as Mixed Question of Law and Fact Cannot Be Decided on Pleadings Alone: Allahabad HC

The Allahabad High Court ruled that when a plaintiff alleges late discovery of a key document affecting limitation, the issue cannot be resolved at the threshold under Order VII Rule 11 CPC without evidence. This protects plaintiffs from premature dismissal where factual disputes over knowledge or concealment require trial, reinforcing procedural fairness in property disputes.

Section 11(6) Arbitration Act | Limitation Objections Must Be Decided by Arbitrator If Court Grants Liberty to Arbitrate : MP HC Jabalpur
Case Law Analysis
|Madhya Pradesh High Court

Section 11(6) Arbitration Act | Limitation Objections Must Be Decided by Arbitrator If Court Grants Liberty to Arbitrate : MP HC Jabalpur

MP High Court rules that when a court grants liberty to arbitrate while excluding the limitation period, objections on limitation must be decided by the arbitrator, not the court. This reinforces the kompetenz-kompetenz principle, shifting the burden of limitation disputes to arbitration proceedings where prior litigation excluded the relevant period.