Topic

Evidence-Based Adjudication

2 articlesLatest July 2026
Pranay Sethi Principles | Bombay HC Revises Disability Assessment from 8% to 10% Based on Evidence : Bombay HC
Case Law Analysis
|Bombay High Court

Pranay Sethi Principles | Bombay HC Revises Disability Assessment from 8% to 10% Based on Evidence : Bombay HC

Bombay High Court enhances motor accident compensation by applying the Pranay Sethi principles, revising the disability assessment from 8% to 10% after evaluating evidentiary gaps. The ruling underscores the need for tribunals to balance equity in income and disability calculations, ensuring compensation reflects actual loss of earning capacity.

Section 23(2) PWDV Act | Interim Maintenance Orders Require Evidence-Based Adjudication, Not Ex Parte Affidavits : Karnataka HC
Case Law Analysis
|Karnataka High Court

Section 23(2) PWDV Act | Interim Maintenance Orders Require Evidence-Based Adjudication, Not Ex Parte Affidavits : Karnataka HC

The Karnataka High Court ruled that interim maintenance under the PWDV Act cannot be granted solely on ex parte affidavits. Courts must record evidence to assess financial capacity and need before awarding maintenance, ensuring fairness to both parties. This sets a precedent for evidence-based adjudication in domestic violence cases.