#Doctrine of Election

Pensioners who elected to retain their pre-7th CPC commuted value forfeit the right to later claim differential payments arising from subsequent pension revisions. This ruling enforces the Doctrine of Election, preventing double recovery and ensuring finality in pension benefits under the CCS (Commutation) Rules, 1981 - directly impacting thousands of central government retirees seeking retroactive adjustments.

The Karnataka High Court reaffirmed the doctrine of election, holding that a party cannot simultaneously accept benefits under a settlement agreement and later challenge its obligations. The ruling dismisses attempts to withdraw deposited funds while contesting the same instrument, reinforcing contractual estoppel in commercial disputes.