
Case Law Analysis
|Karnataka High Court
Section 138 NI Act | Surrender Deed Crystallizing Debt Triggers Presumption of Liability; Blank Cheques with Signature Attract Statutory Presumption : Karnataka HC
The Karnataka High Court held that when a surrender deed formally crystallizes a debt, the issuance of a signed blank cheque automatically triggers the statutory presumption under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The accused’s failure to rebut this presumption-through silence, lack of forensic challenge, or admission of liability in IT returns-was fatal to the defense, reinforcing that procedural inaction cannot override statutory presumptions in commercial disputes.
