Section 405/420 IPC | Earnest Money Not Entrustment; Breach of Contract ≠ Cheating in Land Sale : P&H HC

The High Court quashed criminal breach of trust and cheating charges, holding earnest money under an agreement to sell is not 'entrustment' under Section 405 IPC, and mere failure to execute a sale deed is a civil breach, not cheating under Section 420 IPC. The ruling prevents criminal law from being misused to enforce property contracts.

Cassie News NetworkCassie News Network
Nov 19, 2026, 12:17 AM
•11 min read
Be the first to share in your circle
Section 405/420 IPC | Earnest Money Not Entrustment; Breach of Contract ≠ Cheating in Land Sale : P&H HC

The Punjab and Haryana High Court quashed criminal proceedings against a widow accused of criminal breach of trust and cheating in a land sale dispute, holding that earnest money paid under an agreement to sell does not amount to entrustment under Section 405 IPC and mere failure to execute a sale deed does not constitute cheating under Section 420 IPC.

Background & Facts

The Dispute

The petitioner, Parminder Kaur, a widow, faced criminal proceedings initiated by respondent No.2, Gurnam Singh, a travel agent from Bhogpur. The dispute centered on agricultural land measuring 8 kanals 9 marlas situated at Village Jalalabad, District Jalandhar. Gurnam Singh alleged that the petitioner agreed to sell the land at Rs.20 lakh per acre, executed an agreement to sell on 03.03.2016 after receiving Rs.11 lakh as earnest money, but failed to appear for execution of the sale deed on 05.04.2016 and instead sold the property to another person.

Key Facts

  • The petitioner executed an agreement to sell dated 03.03.2016 before Sub Tehsil Bhogpur after receiving Rs.11,00,000/-, with Sarabjit Singh and Jeet Singh Lambardar as attesting witnesses
  • The sale deed was to be executed on or before 05.04.2016
  • The complainant claimed to have remained present before the Sub Registrar on 05.04.2016 but the petitioner did not turn up
  • It was alleged that co-accused Gurpal Singh Dhillon and Rajesh Puri (a Food and Civil Supply Inspector) were proclaiming in public that they had purchased the property
  • The petitioner executed a sale deed dated 30.03.2016 regarding the same land in favour of Jeewan Puri, wife of Ramesh Puri, for a consideration of Rs.13,80,000/-
  • The petitioner did not deny her signatures on the agreement to sell but alleged they were obtained by misrepresentation
  • Respondent No.2 filed a civil suit for specific performance on 06.04.2016 (Annexure P-1), which was dismissed with costs on 30.10.2023 (Annexure P-7)
  • In the civil suit, the plaintiff could not produce his passbook to show payment of Rs.11 lakh, the two attesting witnesses did not appear for cross-examination, and the plaintiff admitted an agreement to sell dated 01.09.2014 had already been executed between the petitioner and Jeewan Puri

Procedural History

  • 20.06.2016: FIR No.67 registered under Sections 420/34 IPC at Police Station Bhogpur, District Jalandhar (Rural)
  • 16.04.2016: SHO inquiry report recorded agreement to sell and non-appearance of petitioner on 05.04.2016
  • 23.06.2016: Co-accused Gurpal Singh arrested and released on bail next day
  • 22.07.2016: Petitioner granted interim bail by Additional Sessions Judge, Jalandhar
  • 15.01.2018: Trial Court (Judicial Magistrate First Class, Jalandhar) framed charges under Sections 406/34 IPC (Annexure P-5)
  • 17.05.2019: Sessions Judge, Jalandhar dismissed petitioner's revision petition but allowed co-accused Gurpal Singh's revision and discharged him (Annexure P-6)
  • 27.08.2019: Notice of motion issued in present petition under Section 482 CrPC
  • 10.10.2022: High Court directed trial court to adjourn proceedings
  • 14.09.2024: State filed reply and status report
  • 12.11.2026: Judgment reserved
  • 17.11.2026: Judgment pronounced

The Parties' Positions

Petitioner's case: The petitioner is a widow victimized by respondent No.2, who agreed to send her son to America for Rs.22 lakh but sent him to Mexico where he was detained. Respondent No.2 then demanded Rs.5 lakh for his release and obtained the petitioner's signatures on stamp papers and blank papers on the pretext they were required for her son's release. These papers were later converted into the alleged agreement to sell. The petitioner had already entered into an agreement to sell the same land with Jeewan Puri on 01.09.2014. The dispute is purely civil and the civil suit has been dismissed on merits.

State's case: The petitioner agreed to sell her land to the complainant vide agreement to sell dated 03.03.2016 after receiving Rs.11 lakh as earnest money. Instead of honouring the agreement, she executed a sale deed in favour of Jeewan Puri, showing intention to cheat from inception. The petitioner has not denied her signatures and a person is presumed to have signed after understanding contents unless fraud is proved. Only a prima facie case is required at charge framing stage.

Relief Sought

The petitioner sought quashing of the order dated 15.01.2018 framing charges under Sections 406/34 IPC and the order dated 17.05.2019 dismissing her revision petition, and quashing of all proceedings arising out of FIR No.67 dated 20.06.2016 qua the petitioner.

The central questions were: (1) Whether the prosecution material discloses the essential ingredient of entrustment required for an offence under Section 406 IPC when earnest money is paid under an agreement to sell; (2) Whether the allegations disclose dishonest intention at the inception of the transaction to constitute cheating under Section 420 IPC; (3) Whether continuation of criminal proceedings amounts to abuse of process when a civil suit on the same facts has been dismissed.

Arguments Presented

For the Petitioner

Learned counsel argued that no ingredient of criminal breach of trust is made out since no property was ever entrusted to the petitioner. The amount of Rs.11 lakh was paid as part of sale consideration under an agreement to sell, not as entrustment. The petitioner's signatures were obtained by misrepresentation on the pretext of securing her son's release from detention in Mexico. The petitioner had already entered into an agreement to sell with Jeewan Puri on 01.09.2014. Respondent No.2 first availed civil remedy and then registered the FIR to exert pressure. The co-accused has been discharged and nothing was found against Rajesh Puri. Reliance was placed on Radheyshyam and others v. State of Rajasthan and another, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2311, where the Supreme Court held that advance payment under an agreement to sell is not entrustment and mere refusal to register sale does not amount to cheating.

For the Respondent/State

Learned State counsel argued that the petitioner agreed to sell the land, received Rs.11 lakh as earnest money, but executed a sale deed in favour of Jeewan Puri, demonstrating intention to cheat from inception. The petitioner has not denied her signatures and the plea of misrepresentation can only be tested during trial. At the charge framing stage, only a prima facie case is required and evidence cannot be evaluated. The petition is not maintainable as the petitioner has already availed the remedy of revision before the Sessions Judge.

The Court's Analysis

The Court examined the distinction between criminal breach of trust and cheating as explained by the Supreme Court in Delhi Race Club (1940) Limited and others v. State of Uttar Pradesh and another, (2024) 10 SCC 690. The Court noted:

"For cheating, the intention of the accused at the time of inducement should be looked into which may be judged by a subsequent conduct, but for this, the subsequent conduct is not the sole test. Mere breach of contract cannot give rise to a criminal prosecution for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right from the beginning of the transaction i.e. the time when the offence is said to have been committed. Therefore, it is this intention, which is the gist of the offence. Whereas, for the criminal breach of trust, the property must have been entrusted to the accused or he must have dominion over it. The property in respect of which the offence of breach of trust has been committed must be either the property of some person other than the accused or the beneficial interest in or ownership of it must be of some other person. The accused must hold that property on trust of such other person. Although the offence, i.e. the offence of breach of trust and cheating involve dishonest intention, yet they are mutually exclusive and different in basic concept... Once there is a sale, Section 406 of the IPC goes out of picture."

The Court further relied on Rikhab Birani and another v. State of Uttar Pradesh and another, 2025 INSC 512, where the Supreme Court deprecated the failure to distinguish between civil breach of contract and offences under Sections 420 and 406 IPC, and held:

"An offence under Section 406 of the IPC requires entrustment, which carries the implication that a person handing over any property or on whose behalf the property is handed over, continues to be the owner of the said property. Further, the person handing over the property must have confidence in the person taking the property to create a fiduciary relationship between them. A normal transaction of sale or exchange of money/consideration does not amount to entrustment. Clearly, the charge/offence of Section 406 IPC is not even remotely made out."

The Court also referenced S.N. Vijaylakshmi and others v. State of Karnataka and another, 2025 INSC 917, where the Supreme Court held that where the accused were owners with title to the property, Section 406 IPC could not be invoked, and continuation of criminal proceedings alongside civil proceedings on the same issue without element of criminality amounts to abuse of process.

Applying these principles, the Court found that the land always belonged to the petitioner and was never handed over by the complainant to be held for him. The amount of Rs.11 lakh was paid as part of sale consideration under the agreement to sell and did not create any fiduciary relationship. The prosecution material did not show the amount was handed over to be held for the complainant or dealt with in a particular manner on his behalf. Therefore, the foundation of the charge under Section 406 IPC was missing.

Regarding cheating, the Court held that dishonest intention must exist at the time of the promise or representation. The complaint did not allege any false representation at the time of the agreement to sell dated 03.03.2016. The grievance was only non-appearance on 05.04.2016 and sale to another person. The sale deed in favour of Jeewan Puri was executed on 30.03.2016, after the agreement. On the prosecution's own case, the allegations disclosed at best a breach of agreement to sell, not dishonest intention at inception.

The Court also noted that the civil suit filed on 06.04.2016 had been dismissed with costs on 30.10.2023. The plaintiff could not prove payment of Rs.11 lakh, the attesting witnesses did not appear, and the plaintiff admitted the prior agreement with Jeewan Puri. The co-accused had been discharged and no common intention under Section 34 IPC was established.

The Verdict

The petition was allowed. The Court set aside the order dated 15.01.2018 framing charges under Sections 406/34 IPC and the order dated 17.05.2019 dismissing the revision petition. All proceedings arising out of FIR No.67 dated 20.06.2016 registered under Sections 420/34 IPC at Police Station Bhogpur, District Jalandhar (Rural) were quashed qua the petitioner. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, were disposed of.

What This Means For Similar Cases

Earnest Money Is Not Entrustment

Payment of earnest money or part consideration under an agreement to sell does not constitute entrustment under Section 405 IPC. The property remains the seller's and the payment is made in furtherance of a commercial transaction, not a fiduciary relationship. Practitioners must argue that Section 406 IPC requires the complainant to remain the owner of the property entrusted - a normal sale transaction where money passes as consideration cannot satisfy this requirement.

  • The payment must be for holding property on behalf of another, not as sale consideration
  • No fiduciary relationship arises from a standard agreement to sell
  • Courts must identify the specific property allegedly entrusted at charge framing stage

Dishonest Intention Must Exist At Inception

Cheating under Section 420 IPC requires proof of fraudulent or dishonest intention at the very beginning of the transaction. A subsequent breach of contract or failure to perform a promise does not retroactively create criminal liability. Practitioners should scrutinize the complaint for allegations of false representation made at the time of agreement.

  • Mere non-execution of sale deed is not cheating
  • Subsequent sale to third party does not prove initial dishonest intent
  • The complainant must allege deception at the inducement stage

Civil Remedy Availed First Weighs Against Criminal Prosecution

When a complainant first files a civil suit for specific performance and that suit fails on merits, continuation of parallel criminal proceedings on the same facts without an overwhelming element of criminality constitutes abuse of process. The dismissal of the civil suit on evidentiary grounds (failure to prove payment, witnesses not appearing) strengthens the case for quashing.

  • Civil suit dismissed on merits is a relevant factor
  • Failure to prove payment in civil court undermines criminal allegations
  • Co-accused discharge negates common intention under Section 34 IPC

Case Details

PARMINDER KAUR vs STATE OF PUNJAB

PDF
Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Date
2026-11-17
Case Number
CRM-M/35010/2019
Bench
MANISHA BATRA
Counsel
Pet: Mr. R.S. Bajaj
Res: Ms. Ruchika Sabherwal

Frequently Asked Questions

Entrustment requires the property to belong to another person, with the accused holding it on trust or in a fiduciary capacity. A normal sale transaction where money is paid as consideration does not create entrustment, as the payer does not remain the owner of the money paid.
No. Cheating requires dishonest or fraudulent intention at the inception of the transaction. Mere breach of contract or subsequent failure to perform a promise does not constitute cheating unless deception is proven at the time the agreement was made.
Not ipso facto, but if the civil suit is dismissed on merits and the criminal allegations lack an overwhelming element of criminality, continuation of criminal proceedings amounts to abuse of process. The courts must distinguish between civil wrongs and criminal offences.
If the co-accused is discharged for lack of material connecting them to the offence, and no other evidence shows participation in furtherance of common intention, Section 34 IPC cannot be sustained against the remaining accused.
0

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The views expressed are based on the judgment analysis and should not be taken as professional counsel. Please consult with a qualified attorney for advice specific to your situation.