
The Delhi High Court has held that a corporate guarantee furnished by a holding company to a financial institution for its subsidiary's borrowings constitutes a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I of the CGST Act, 2017, even when no consideration is charged. The Court upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 28(2) but read it down to make the 1% per annum deemed value a rebuttable presumption that yields to a lower open market value established by the supplier. The judgment clarifies that the supply is a one-time event at execution, not a continuous supply, and pre-GST guarantees are not taxable unless renewed or extended post-GST.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
A batch of writ petitions was filed by multiple corporate groups - including Sterlite Power Transmission Limited, Renew Private Limited, Jindal Stainless Hisar Limited, Azure Power India Private Limited, Nambi Buildwell Limited, JITF Urban Infrastructure Services Limited, Essar Power Limited, GAIL India Limited, Essar Shipping Limited, Avaada Energy Private Limited, SAEL Limited, Future Brands Limited, ISP Technologies Private Limited, Logix Realtors Private Limited, Hero Future Energies Private Limited, and Hero Solar Energy Private Limited - challenging the imposition of GST on corporate guarantees furnished by holding companies to banks or financial institutions on behalf of their subsidiaries. The petitioners contested show-cause notices and demand orders issued by the Revenue, which sought to tax such guarantees at a deemed value of 1% per annum of the guaranteed amount under Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules, 2017, inserted by Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax dated 26.10.2023 (IN-2023) and amended by Notification No. 12/2024-Central Tax dated 10.07.2024 (IN-2024). The petitioners also challenged Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST dated 27.10.2023 (IC-2023) and Circular No. 225/19/2024-GST dated 11.07.2024 (IC-2024), which clarified the applicability of Rule 28(2).
Key Facts
- The petitioners are holding or group companies that furnished corporate guarantees to banks or financial institutions for loans availed by their subsidiaries or related entities.
- The guarantees were executed without any fee, commission, or consideration from the subsidiaries; several guarantee deeds expressly prohibited any fee while the guaranteed obligations subsisted.
- The petitioners operate in sectors such as power transmission, renewable energy, stainless steel, shipping, and infrastructure, where project financing is routed through Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) that lack independent financial standing.
- The Revenue invoked Section 74 of the CGST Act (extended limitation for fraud/suppression) in several show-cause notices, though the petitioners contended the issue was purely interpretative.
- The GST Council, in its 52nd Meeting (07.10.2023), recommended inserting Rule 28(2) to prescribe a deemed value of 1% per annum for corporate guarantees between related persons, adopting the minimum fee under Rule 10TD of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 (Safe Harbour Rules). The 53rd Meeting (22.06.2024) amended the Rule to add "located in India" and "per annum".
- The petitioners argued that corporate guarantees are shareholder activities to protect investment, not business activities; that no consideration flows to the holding company; that the guarantee is an actionable claim or security excluded from GST; and that Rule 28(2) is arbitrary, retrospective, and violative of Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 246A, and 265 of the Constitution.
Procedural History
- 26.10.2023: Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax (IN-2023) issued, inserting Rule 28(2) in CGST Rules, 2017.
- 27.10.2023: Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST (IC-2023) issued, clarifying applicability of Rule 28(2).
- 10.07.2024: Notification No. 12/2024-Central Tax (IN-2024) issued, amending Rule 28(2) to add "located in India" and "per annum".
- 11.07.2024: Circular No. 225/19/2024-GST (IC-2024) issued, further clarifying applicability.
- 2024-2025: Multiple writ petitions filed before the Delhi High Court (W.P.(C) 2966/2024, 10924/2024, 14622/2024, 15738/2024, 17559/2024, 12955/2025, 13341/2025, 13358/2025, 19506/2025, 214/2025, 5238/2025, 6436/2025, 7639/2025, 8990/2025, 280/2026, 281/2026).
- 27.10.2026: Judgment reserved.
- 17.11.2026: Judgment pronounced.
The Parties' Positions
Petitioners: Corporate guarantee is not a supply; it is a shareholder activity, lacks consideration, is an actionable claim/security, and Rule 28(2) is ultra vires, arbitrary, and retrospective. IC-2023/IC-2024 exceed Section 168. Respondents (Union of India): Corporate guarantee is a supply under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I (related-party supply without consideration); classified as service under Section 7(1A) read with Schedule II Entry 5(e); Rule 28(2) is a valid valuation rule under Sections 15(4), 15(5), 164; 1% derived from GST Council deliberations and Safe Harbour Rules; Circulars are consistent with statute.
Relief Sought
The petitioners sought quashing of Rule 28(2), IN-2023, IN-2024, IC-2023, IC-2024, and all show-cause notices/demand orders; alternatively, reading down of Rule 28(2) to make deemed value rebuttable; declaration that pre-GST guarantees and guarantees between 01.07.2017-25.10.2023 are not subject to Rule 28(2).
The Legal Issue
The central questions were: (1) Whether a corporate guarantee by a holding company for its subsidiary without consideration constitutes a "supply of services" under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I of the CGST Act, 2017, and if so, who is the recipient? (2) Whether such guarantee is excluded as an "actionable claim" under Entry 6 of Schedule III or as a "security" under Section 2(102)? (3) Whether Rule 28(2) prescribing deemed value of 1% per annum is intra vires the Act and Constitution? (4) When does the supply occur, and what is the effect on pre-GST guarantees, guarantees between 01.07.2017-25.10.2023, and the retrospective operation of IN-2024? (5) Whether IC-2023 and IC-2024 are ultra vires Section 168?
Arguments Presented
For the Petitioners
The petitioners contended that a corporate guarantee is not a supply because it is a shareholder activity to protect investment, not a business activity under Section 2(17). No consideration flows to the holding company as defined in Section 2(31); the loan to the subsidiary is not consideration for the guarantee. They relied on Commissioner of CGST v. Edelweiss Financial Services Ltd. (service tax regime) and D.P. Jain & Co. Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (Bombay HC) to argue that gratuitous guarantees are not taxable. The guarantee is an actionable claim under Section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (contingent debt), excluded by Entry 6 of Schedule III. Alternatively, it is a "security" under Section 2(h) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, excluded from "services" by Section 2(102). Rule 28(2) is ultra vires: it creates a taxable event, not merely a valuation rule; the 1% figure is arbitrary, borrowed from optional Safe Harbour Rules, and operates as a fixed minimum even where open market value is lower, violating Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 246A, 265. IN-2024's retrospective application from 26.10.2023 imposes substantive liability on concluded transactions. The guarantee is a one-time undertaking, not a continuous supply under Section 2(33); time of supply is date of execution under Section 13(2)(b). IC-2023/IC-2024 legislate administratively, creating taxable events, identifying supplier/recipient, fixing time of supply and valuation, exceeding Section 168.
For the Respondents
The Union of India argued that Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I taxes related-person supplies even without consideration, as such transactions are not at arm's length. The guarantee substitutes a bank guarantee; the holding company extends its creditworthiness, enabling the subsidiary to obtain finance - a real service. The recipient is the subsidiary under Section 2(93)(c) (person to whom service rendered). Schedule II Entry 5(e) (agreeing to do an act) classifies it as service. Rule 28(2) is a valid valuation rule under Sections 15(4), 15(5), 164, recommended by GST Council. The 1% figure addresses genuine difficulty in finding comparables for intra-group guarantees, as recorded in the 52nd GST Council Meeting agenda. Gameskraft Technologies (Supreme Court) upheld broad amplitude of "supply" and validity of Council-recommended rules. Edelweiss is distinguishable as service tax required consideration in definition. The guarantee is not an actionable claim (no debt owed by guarantor until default) nor a security under SCRA. IC-2023/IC-2024 are collateral to Rule 28(2), not standalone levy-creating circulars. For pre-26.10.2023 period, valuation falls under Rules 28, 30, 31; Rule 28(2) applies prospectively. The "per annum" in IN-2024 is clarificatory; "located in India" is beneficial (exports excluded).
The Court's Analysis
The Court identified five issues and analysed each in depth.
On Issue (a) - Supply and Recipient: The Court held that a corporate guarantee constitutes a supply of services. The guarantor assumes the risk of the subsidiary's default, extending its creditworthiness - something of value that is neither goods, money, nor securities, hence a "service" under Section 2(102). This is fortified by four indicators: (i) assumption of credit risk for a fee is a recognised commercial service (bank guarantees are taxable); (ii) statutory provisions (Section 186 Companies Act, 2013; Section 5(8)(i) IBC; Section 92B Income Tax Act, 1961; Section 163 Income Tax Act, 2025) treat guarantees as substantive financial commitments; (iii) Ind AS 109 requires financial guarantee contracts to be measured at fair value at initial recognition, confirming economic value; (iv) petitioners themselves admitted SPVs lack independent financial standing and parent's guarantee is a necessity. The motive (protecting investment) does not alter the transaction's character; Section 2(17) definition of "business" is transaction-centric and indifferent to purpose. The supply is made in the course of business under Section 2(17)(b) (incidental/ancillary to trade). The recipient is the subsidiary under Section 2(93)(c) - the person to whom the service (credit support) is rendered. The lender is merely the promisee; the guarantee exists for the subsidiary's benefit. The Court rejected the "single tripartite arrangement" argument: loan (by lender) and guarantee (by holding company) are supplies by different suppliers, not a composite supply under Section 8.
"The service consists in the assumption of the risk of the related person's default and the consequent extension of the guarantor's creditworthiness to it. The recipient of the said service is the related person on whose behalf the guarantee is furnished, under Section 2(93)(c) of the Act of 2017."
On Issue (b) - Exclusions: The guarantee is not an actionable claim under Entry 6 of Schedule III. The subsidiary receives credit support, not a claim; it acquires no right against the guarantor. The claim (if any) arises in favour of the lender, who is not the recipient under Entry 2. The Court declined to decide whether the lender's right is an actionable claim, as it is irrelevant to the supply from guarantor to subsidiary. The guarantee is not a "security" under Section 2(102) read with SCRA; a guarantee is collateral in a generic sense, not a marketable instrument under Section 2(h) SCRA.
On Issue (c) - Validity of Rule 28(2): The Court upheld Rule 28(2) as intra vires Sections 15 and 164. The four components of tax (taxable event, person liable, rate, measure) are in the statute; delegation of valuation detail is permissible. GST Council recommendations carry persuasive value but are not binding (Mohit Minerals). However, the 1% deemed value cannot operate as a fixed minimum. Four reasons: (i) GST Council agenda recorded banks charge 0.5%-3%, sometimes nothing - true value can be below 1%; (ii) 1% taken from optional Safe Harbour Rules, converted into compulsory minimum; (iii) Rule 28(2)'s non-obstante clause overrides Rule 28(1)'s open market value method even where supplier can show lower value; (iv) open market value can be established via Ind AS 109 fair value, transfer pricing benchmarks, credit rating differentials. The Court read down Rule 28(2): the deemed value is a rebuttable presumption yielding to a lower open market value established by the supplier on cogent material. The burden is on the supplier; the proper officer may test the material. The proviso (deeming invoice value where recipient has full ITC) is valid - classification based on GST design (revenue neutrality where full credit available). Differential treatment for recipients without full ITC (e.g., exempt output suppliers) results from exemption, not discrimination.
"The deemed value of 1% of the amount of the guarantee per annum shall yield to a lower open market value, where the supplier establishes such value on cogent and verifiable material. The burden lies on the supplier, and the proper officer is entitled to test the material. Thus, the deemed value is a rebuttable presumption, and not a fixed minimum."
On Issue (d) - Time of Supply and Temporal Application: The supply (assumption of risk) occurs at execution. Continued subsistence is not a fresh supply; each renewal/extension/enhancement is a fresh supply. A corporate guarantee is not a continuous supply under Section 2(33) - no periodic payment obligations; the deemed value fiction under Rule 28(2) relates only to value, cannot alter definitions or create payment obligations. Time of supply: if invoice issued timely, Section 13(2)(a); else Section 13(2)(b) (date of provision of service = date of execution). Section 13(2)(c) (recipient's books) is residuary and does not apply; Ind AS 24 disclosure does not constitute "showing receipt of services". The expression "per annum" measures value by reference to tenure; tax computed upfront for entire tenure at execution. However, Section 34 allows credit note if guarantee released early (value exceeds taxable value for actual period). For long-term guarantees causing cash flow burden, the Court suggested the Government frame rules under Section 148 for annual instalment collection without altering the single supply character.
- Pre-GST guarantees (before 01.07.2017): Supply complete before Act; continued existence not fresh supply. Not taxable unless renewed/extended/enhanced post-GST. Adjudicating authority to examine deed-wise.
- Guarantees 01.07.2017 to 25.10.2023: Taxable from 01.07.2017, but Rule 28(2) does not apply (introduced 26.10.2023, no retrospective effect under Section 164(3)). Valuation under Rules 28, 30, 31 then in force, on material specific to each guarantee. Rule 31 cannot be used to apply 1% uniformly.
- IN-2024: "Located in India" (beneficial, exports excluded) and "per annum" (clarificatory) apply from 26.10.2023. Retrospective challenge fails as beneficial.
On Issue (e) - Circulars: IC-2023/IC-2024 are not ultra vires Section 168. They reflect the law, are consistent with the statute, and assist field formations. Circulars bind authorities, not courts; but here they are collateral to Rule 28(2), not standalone levy-creating instruments.
The Verdict
The petitioners succeeded in part. The Court held: (1) Corporate guarantee by holding company for subsidiary is a taxable supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, even without consideration; recipient is the subsidiary. (2) Not excluded as actionable claim or security. (3) Rule 28(2) is intra vires but read down: 1% deemed value is a rebuttable presumption yielding to lower open market value established by supplier; proviso (full ITC) upheld. (4) Supply is one-time at execution; not continuous supply; time of supply is date of execution (Section 13(2)(b) if invoice not issued timely). Tax computed upfront for entire tenure; Section 34 credit note available for early release. Government may frame Section 148 rules for annual instalment collection. (5) Pre-GST guarantees not taxable unless renewed/extended/enhanced post-GST. (6) Guarantees 01.07.2017-25.10.2023 taxable but valued under old Rules (28, 30, 31), not Rule 28(2). (7) IN-2024 amendments apply from 26.10.2023; "located in India" beneficial, "per annum" clarificatory. (8) IC-2023/IC-2024 not ultra vires Section 168. Writ petitions disposed of accordingly.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Corporate Guarantees Are Taxable Supplies - But Valuation Is Not Automatic
Practitioners must advise clients that corporate guarantees between related parties are now firmly established as taxable supplies under GST, regardless of consideration. However, the 1% per annum deemed value under Rule 28(2) is not a fixed floor. Taxpayers can and should maintain documentation to establish open market value - using Ind AS 109 fair value measurements, transfer pricing benchmarks, credit rating agency reports, or comparable third-party guarantee commissions - to rebut the presumption. The burden of proof lies on the supplier, but the proper officer must evaluate the material objectively.
- Actionable takeaway: For every corporate guarantee executed post-26.10.2023, prepare a valuation file at inception: obtain independent credit rating assessment, document comparable bank guarantee rates for similar risk profiles, and record the rationale for any fee (or absence thereof). This contemporaneous evidence will be critical if the Revenue challenges a value lower than 1%.
- Actionable takeaway: Where the recipient (subsidiary) is eligible for full ITC, the proviso to Rule 28(2) applies - the invoice value (even if nil) is deemed the value. Ensure ITC eligibility is documented and reconciled in GSTR-2A/2B.
One-Time Supply at Execution - No Annual Recurrence
The judgment definitively settles that a corporate guarantee is a single supply at execution, not a continuous supply. This means:
-
GST liability crystallises fully at execution for the entire tenure.
-
No fresh supply arises each year merely because the guarantee subsists.
-
Renewal, extension, or enhancement of guarantee amount triggers a new supply for the incremental period/amount.
-
Invocation is performance, not a new supply.
-
Actionable takeaway: For long-term guarantees (e.g., 10-15 year project finance), the upfront GST cost (1% × tenure × guaranteed amount, unless rebutted) can be significant. Advise clients to factor this into project financial models and negotiate with lenders on who bears the GST cost.
-
Actionable takeaway: If a guarantee is released early (e.g., loan repaid in year 5 of 10), file a credit note under Section 34 within the prescribed time limit to recover excess tax paid. Maintain tracking of guarantee release dates.
Pre-GST and Transition-Period Guarantees: Deed-Wise Analysis Required
The Court drew clear temporal lines:
-
Pre-01.07.2017 guarantees: Not taxable unless renewed/extended/enhanced post-GST. Adjudicating authorities must examine each deed for post-GST modifications.
-
01.07.2017 to 25.10.2023: Taxable, but valued under Rules 28, 30, 31 (open market value, like-kind value, cost-plus, residual method) - not Rule 28(2). The Revenue cannot apply 1% retrospectively via Rule 31.
-
Post-26.10.2023: Rule 28(2) applies (read down).
-
Actionable takeaway: For guarantees executed in the transition period, compile evidence of valuation methodology adopted (or that should have been adopted) under the then-applicable Rules. If the Revenue issues demands applying 1% for this period, challenge them as retrospective application of Rule 28(2).
-
Actionable takeaway: For pre-GST guarantees still subsisting, audit whether any board resolution, amendment deed, or lender correspondence constitutes renewal/extension/enhancement post-01.07.2017. Absent such, no GST liability.
Circulars Are Interpretative Aids - Not Law-Creating Instruments
IC-2023 and IC-2024 were upheld as consistent with the statute, but the Court reiterated that circulars bind departmental officers, not courts or taxpayers. They cannot create a taxable event, deem a recipient, or fix time of supply where the statute does not.
- Actionable takeaway: In adjudication or appellate proceedings, rely on the statutory text and the Court's interpretation, not the Circulars. If a Circular's interpretation diverges from the statute (e.g., on time of supply or continuous supply), the statute prevails.
Section 148 Mechanism for Instalment Payment - Watch This Space
The Court explicitly invited the Government to frame rules under Section 148 for annual instalment collection of GST on long-term guarantees. This would alleviate cash flow burden without altering the single-supply character.
- Actionable takeaway: Monitor for notifications under Section 148. If issued, clients with long-term guarantees may opt for instalment payment. Until then, full upfront payment is required (subject to Section 34 credit note for early release).
OECD Guidelines and Transfer Pricing Principles: Limited Relevance
The Court held the CGST Act is a standalone statute; OECD Guidelines do not control interpretation. However, transfer pricing benchmarks (including Safe Harbour) may be used as evidence of open market value to rebut the 1% presumption.
- Actionable takeaway: When establishing open market value, transfer pricing documentation (Form 3CEB, benchmarking studies) can serve as "cogent and verifiable material." Align GST valuation documentation with transfer pricing positions to avoid inconsistencies.
Actionable Checklist for Practitioners
- Identify all corporate guarantees issued by group companies post-01.07.2017.
- Classify by execution date: pre-GST, transition (01.07.2017-25.10.2023), post-Rule 28(2) (26.10.2023 onwards).
- For post-26.10.2023 guarantees: prepare open market valuation file at execution; assess ITC eligibility of recipient.
- For transition-period guarantees: ensure valuation under Rules 28/30/31 is documented; resist 1% application.
- For pre-GST guarantees: confirm no post-GST renewal/extension/enhancement; if none, no GST.
- Track guarantee tenure, release dates, and loan repayment schedules for Section 34 credit notes.
- Advise on GST cost allocation in inter-company agreements and loan documentation.
- Monitor Section 148 notification for instalment payment option.






