Case Law Analysis

Welfare Principle Overrides Section 6 HMGA Natural Guardianship; UK Custody Order Enforced Via Habeas Corpus : Punjab & Haryana HC

The Punjab & Haryana HC granted custody of a 4-year-old British child to her mother via habeas corpus, enforcing a UK High Court order that found the father's removal of the child to India wrongful. The court ruled the child's welfare prevails over the father's natural guardianship claim under Section 6 HMGA, upholding comity of courts in transnational custody disputes.

Cassie News NetworkCassie News Network
Nov 17, 2026, 10:38 PM
•10 min read
Be the first to share in your circle
Welfare Principle Overrides Section 6 HMGA Natural Guardianship; UK Custody Order Enforced Via Habeas Corpus : Punjab & Haryana HC

The Punjab and Haryana High Court allowed a habeas corpus petition filed by a mother seeking custody of her four-year-old daughter from the father and paternal grandparents, holding that the child's welfare is paramount and that foreign court orders directing return of the child must be respected under the doctrine of comity of courts. The Court directed the father to hand over custody to the mother on 18 November 2026, with police assistance if necessary, and permitted the father limited visitation rights.

Background & Facts

The Dispute

The petitioner, Taina, filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution read with Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, seeking a writ of habeas corpus to secure custody of her minor daughter Aradhana Sandhu from respondent No.5 (Rajender Sandhu, the father) and respondents No.6 and 7 (paternal grandparents). The child, born in the United Kingdom, is a British citizen. The father had brought the child to India in June 2025 on the pretext of a summer vacation and left her with his parents, returning alone to the UK.

Key Facts

  • The petitioner cleared IELTS in October 2019 and planned higher studies in the UK
  • Marriage solemnised with respondent No.5 on 21.10.2020
  • Couple shifted to UK on student visa on 08.03.2021; petitioner now on skilled worker visa
  • Female child Aradhana Sandhu born 05.04.2022 in the UK (British citizen by birth)
  • Relations strained by end of 2024; allegations of abusive conduct by respondent No.5
  • June 2025: Respondent No.5 took child to India for summer vacation but left her with respondents No.6 and 7; returned to UK alone
  • 11.11.2025: Complete separation; all communication ceased
  • Petitioner initiated custody proceedings in UK courts (Annexure P-5)

Procedural History

  • 25.03.2026: High Court of Justice, Family Division, London (Annexure P-6) held on provisional basis that child was wrongfully removed to India by respondent No.5 and petitioner prevented from exercising parental responsibility
  • 01.04.2026: Enforcement measures initiated (Annexure P-7)
  • 15.04.2026: UK High Court reiterated child habitually resident in England and Wales; directed respondent No.5 to return child (Annexure P-8)
  • 05.05.2026: UK High Court directed child to continue as ward of court; respondent No.5 to return child by 20.05.2026; Indian enforcement authorities requested to assist (Annexure P-10)
  • 03.11.2026: Matter reserved for judgment
  • 13.11.2026: Judgment pronounced

The Parties' Positions

Petitioner: Mother is natural guardian; child under five years; UK courts have directed return; welfare of child requires custody with mother in UK where she has support systems and citizenship rights.

Respondents No.5 to 7: Child well settled with father and grandparents; habeas corpus not proper remedy; petitioner should file under Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act; allegations of petitioner's extra-marital affair and taxing work schedule make her unsuitable.

Relief Sought

Petitioner sought handover of custody of minor child Aradhana Sandhu, enforcement of UK court orders, and police assistance for smooth transition.

The central questions were: (1) Whether a writ of habeas corpus is maintainable for custody of a minor child when the child is in the custody of a parent; (2) Whether the welfare of the child overrides the father's status as natural guardian under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956; (3) Whether Indian courts should give effect to UK court orders directing return of the child under the doctrine of comity of courts.

Arguments Presented

For the Petitioner

Learned counsel Ms. Manisha Nehra argued that the mother being a natural guardian and the girl child being less than five years of age, custody must be handed over to the petitioner. Reliance was placed on Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan, 2020 AIR SC 577, where the Supreme Court held habeas corpus maintainable even if child is with a parent. Coordinate Bench decisions in Mandeep Kaur v. State of Punjab, 2021(3) RCR (Civil) 451, and Harjeet Kaur v. State of Punjab (CRWP No.7195 of 2026, decided 10.09.2026) were cited. The UK court orders directing return of the child were emphasized.

For the Respondent

Learned counsel Ms. Arshdeep Kaur for respondents No.5 to 7 opposed the petition, contending the child is well settled with the father and grandparents. It was argued that habeas corpus is not the appropriate remedy and the petitioner should approach a competent court under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956. Reliance was placed on Nithya Anand Raghavan v. State of NCT of Delhi, Criminal Appeal No.972 of 2017 (decided 03.07.2017); Poonam Kalsi v. State of Punjab, CRWP No.7913 of 2020 (decided 20.04.2022); Jyotsna Goel v. State of Haryana, CRWP No.55 of 2026 (decided 24.03.2026); Rimpy v. State of Punjab, CRWP No.1439 of 2025 (decided 13.02.2025); and Reetu Verma v. State of Haryana, LPA No.3716 of 2018 (decided 23.05.2019). Allegations of petitioner's extra-marital affair and demanding work schedule were raised.

The Court's Analysis

The Court began by affirming that habeas corpus is maintainable even when a child is in the custody of a parent. Citing Yashita Sahu, the Court quoted the Supreme Court: "It is too late in the day to urge that a writ of habeas corpus is not maintainable if the child is in the custody of another parent. The law in this regard has developed a lot over a period of time but now it is a settled position that the court can invoke its extraordinary writ jurisdiction for the best interest of the child." The Court also relied on Tejaswini Gaud v. Shekhar Jagdish Prasad Tewari, 2019 AIR SC 2318, where the Apex Court held that habeas corpus "is a medium through which the custody of the child is addressed to the discretion of the court" and is maintainable "where it is proved that the detention of a minor child by a parent or others was illegal and without any authority of law." A recent decision in Suryakanth M. Raikar v. State of Karnataka (SLP (Crl.) No.8172 of 2026, decided 19.08.2026) was also noted.

"The position of law which, therefore, emerges is that though ordinarily, the basis for the issuance of a writ of habeas corpus is illegal detention. However, it is equally well settled that the welfare of a child is the most relevant issue in the case of custody of a child. The mere availability of an alternative remedy of filing a petition under the provisions of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 or any other relevant statute would not be treated as a hindrance in the issuance of a writ of habeas corpus, especially where such remedy, in the particular facts of a case is not an efficacious remedy."

The Court examined Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, which provides that the father is the natural guardian and in his absence the mother, but custody of a child below five years would normally be with the mother. The Court interacted with the parties and the child, noting the child was "too small to interact" but when asked to go to her mother, "she looked towards her father seeking a nod from him. On she having been re-assured by the Court, she went to the lap of her mother and appeared to be quite comfortable with her."

On comity of courts, the Court cited Yashita Sahu again: "the doctrine of comity of Courts is a very healthy doctrine and that if Courts in different jurisdictions do not respect the orders passed by each others, it will lead to contradictory orders being passed in different jurisdictions." The UK courts had repeatedly directed return of the child, finding wrongful removal and habitual residence in England and Wales.

Weighing all factors, the Court held: "Concededly, the minor child was born in the United Kingdom and is, therefore, a British citizen by birth. The mother of the child is in the United Kingdom. The father is presently in India. Whether he goes back to the United Kingdom or not is not known. For a child aged under five years and more so, when it is a girl child, the mother would be in a better position to look after the child... the child would have more support and facilities in the United Kingdom especially since she is a British citizen and her mother is gainfully employed there."

The Court dismissed allegations against the mother: "The factum of the petitioner being in a relationship with some other person, even if taken to be true, would not lead this Court to a conclusion that she would not look after the child."

The Verdict

The petition was allowed with the following directions: (i) Respondent No.5 shall hand over custody of Aradhana Sandhu to the petitioner on 18.11.2026 at 11.00 A.M. at the petitioner's parental house; (ii) In case of failure, the Senior Superintendent of Police, Nawanshahr and the SHO of the concerned area shall ensure handover; (iii) Parties are at liberty to pursue final custody under relevant statute, uninfluenced by this order; (iv) If respondent No.5 goes to the UK, he may meet the child every Sunday for two hours between 10.00 A.M. and 5.00 P.M. or video call for 15-30 minutes, subject to UK court orders; if he stays in India, video call as above; (v) Police to ensure smooth transition without mental trauma to the child.

What This Means For Similar Cases

Habeas Corpus Remains Available for Parental Custody Disputes

The judgment reaffirms that habeas corpus is not barred merely because a child is with a parent. Practitioners should not hesitate to invoke Article 226 when a child's detention by a parent is alleged to be illegal, especially where foreign court orders exist. The Yashita Sahu principle that "the court can invoke its extraordinary writ jurisdiction for the best interest of the child" is now firmly entrenched.

  • File habeas corpus without waiting for statutory proceedings under HMGA
  • Emphasize welfare of the child as the paramount consideration
  • Cite Yashita Sahu, Tejaswini Gaud, and Suryakanth Raikar as the governing trilogy

Foreign Court Orders Carry Weight Through Comity of Courts

Indian courts will respect foreign custody orders under the doctrine of comity, particularly when they find wrongful removal and habitual residence abroad. The UK court's repeated directions (25.03.2026, 15.04.2026, 05.05.2026) were treated as persuasive, if not binding.

  • Attach all foreign court orders as annexures
  • Highlight findings of habitual residence and wrongful removal
  • Argue that non-compliance would create contradictory jurisdictional orders

Mother's Custody Presumption for Children Under Five Prevails

Section 6 HMGA's statutory preference for mother's custody of children under five was applied decisively, overriding the father's natural guardianship status. The child's British citizenship, mother's UK residence and employment, and the child's comfort with the mother during court interaction were determinative.

  • For children under five, lead with Section 6 HMGA
  • Establish mother's capacity: residence, employment, support systems
  • Document child's comfort and bonding with mother
  • Allegations of moral turpitude against mother (extra-marital affair) do not automatically disqualify her

Police Assistance Can Be Directed for Enforcement

The Court's direction to SSP and SHO to ensure handover provides a practical enforcement mechanism. Practitioners should specifically pray for police assistance in the petition to avoid separate execution proceedings.

  • Include SSP and SHO as respondents or seek directions against them
  • Specify date, time, and place for handover in the prayer
  • Request court-supervised transition to prevent trauma

Case Details

TAINA vs STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS

PDF
Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Date
2026-11-13
Case Number
CRWP/7005/2026
Bench
VIKRAM AGGARWAL
Counsel
Pet: Manisha Nehra
Res: Ravinder Singh, DAG, Punjab, Arshdeep Kaur

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. The Supreme Court in Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan (2020) held it is settled law that habeas corpus is maintainable even if the child is in the custody of another parent, as the court can invoke its extraordinary writ jurisdiction for the best interest of the child.
No. Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 expressly provides that custody of a child below five years would normally be with the mother, notwithstanding the father's status as natural guardian.
Yes. Under the doctrine of comity of courts, Indian courts respect foreign custody orders, particularly where they find wrongful removal and habitual residence in the foreign jurisdiction. Non-compliance would lead to contradictory orders across jurisdictions.
No. The Court held that even if such allegations are true, they would not lead to a conclusion that the mother would not look after the child. Welfare of the child, not moral judgment of the parent, is the paramount consideration.
0

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The views expressed are based on the judgment analysis and should not be taken as professional counsel. Please consult with a qualified attorney for advice specific to your situation.