
The Supreme Court has upheld the NCLAT's decision to set aside the approval of Twinstar Technologies' resolution plan for Videocon Industries and twelve group companies, ruling that payment to dissenting financial creditors through non-convertible debentures redeemable over six years does not satisfy the "payment" requirement under Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code. The Court also held that the Committee of Creditors does not become functus officio upon approving a resolution plan and retains the power to reconsider its decision, particularly when the plan's approval is challenged in statutory appeals. In a related ruling, the Court held that foreign oil and gas assets held through subsidiary companies cannot be included in the CIRP of the holding company, as the Code's statutory scheme expressly excludes subsidiary assets from the corporate debtor's estate under Explanation (b) to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d).
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The appeals arose from the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) of Videocon Industries Limited (VIL) and twelve other Videocon group companies, as well as VOVL Limited (VOVL), a wholly owned subsidiary of VIL. The primary controversy centred on two distinct issues: (i) whether the resolution plan submitted by Twinstar Technologies Limited (the Successful Resolution Applicant or SRA) complied with statutory requirements for payment to dissenting financial creditors, and (ii) whether foreign oil and gas assets held through VIL's subsidiaries could be included in VIL's CIRP.
Key Facts
- Applications under Section 7 of the Code were filed by State Bank of India and other creditors against thirteen Videocon group companies, including VIL, admitted by NCLT between 06.06.2018 and 25.09.2018.
- NCLT, Mumbai directed consolidation of the CIRPs of the thirteen corporate debtors on 08.08.2019.
- The Resolution Professional invited expressions of interest on 11.10.2019 and issued the Information Memorandum with request for resolution plans on 26.11.2019.
- Eleven resolution plans were received and opened in the 15th CoC meeting on 02.09.2020. Fair value and liquidation value were estimated at Rs. 4,069.95 crores and Rs. 2,568.13 crores respectively.
- On 07.11.2020, the SRA submitted an amended resolution plan with total financial outlay of Rs. 2,962.02 crores, providing for upfront payment of Rs. 200 crores to financial creditors, Rs. 52 crores to workmen/employees, Rs. 10 crores to operational creditors, and NCDs of aggregate face value Rs. 2,700 crores at 6.65% annual coupon, redeemable in five instalments starting 25 months after closing date.
- Clause 3.5.1 provided dissenting financial creditors would not be paid less than liquidation value with priority per Regulation 38(1). Clause 3.5.7 stated payment would be made "in all circumstances and in any event" strictly as per Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b).
- In the 19th CoC meeting on 11.11.2020, both compliant plans and the promoter's Section 12A proposal were put to vote simultaneously. SBI Caps circulated a distribution calculation showing dissenting creditors would receive Rs. 114.21 crores.
- Voting concluded on 11.12.2020: SRA's plan approved by 95.09% voting share. Four financial creditors dissented: Bank of Maharashtra (1.97%), IFCI Limited (1.03%), SIDBI (0.053%), ABG Shipyard Limited (0.024%). Section 12A proposal rejected by 98.14%.
- On 12.12.2020, RP issued Letter of Intent to SRA, accepted with performance bank guarantee of Rs. 296.20 crores.
- RP filed application for approval on 16.12.2020 (I.A. No. 196 of 2021). Form H estimated dissenting creditors' payout at Rs. 105.23 crores.
- Supreme Court delivered Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association v. NBCC (India) Ltd. on 24.03.2021, holding payment to dissenting financial creditors under Section 30(2)(b) can only be in money.
- Bank of Maharashtra filed objection (I.A. No. 982 of 2021) citing Jaypee Kensington and discrepancy between Form H and SBI Caps calculation. CoC stated dues would be paid upfront in cash per Jaypee Kensington.
Procedural History
- 08.06.2021: NCLT approved resolution plan under Section 31(1), directing dissenting financial creditors be paid liquidation value in cash upfront before any payment to assenting creditors.
- 19.07.2021: NCLAT stayed approval order and directed status quo ante, noting deferment of bulk payment via NCDs over six years.
- 18.09.2021: CoC (through SBI, representing ~94.98% voting share) filed affidavit seeking reconsideration of plan approval in larger public interest.
- 05.01.2022: NCLAT judgment set aside plan approval, holding: (i) NCD payment structure violated Section 30(2)(b); (ii) NCLT's cash payment direction modified the plan impermissibly; (iii) CoC not functus officio and could reconsider; (iv) CCI approval not obtained under proviso to Section 31(4).
- 12.01.2022: CoC resolved by 97% to invite fresh expressions of interest; Form G published 18.01.2022.
- 14.02.2022: Supreme Court issued notice, asked CoC not to proceed further.
- 14.05.2026: NCLAT judgment in Group II appeals set aside NCLT order dated 12.02.2020 including foreign oil/gas assets in VIL's CIRP, upheld NCLT orders dated 26.06.2024 in VOVL's CIRP approving BPRL's ROFR exercise.
- 16.11.2026: Supreme Court judgment dismissing all appeals.
The Parties' Positions
SRA (Twinstar Technologies): Contended CoC becomes functus officio upon Section 30(4) approval; no power to reconsider post-approval; NCLAT cannot remit for fresh process; plan exceeds liquidation value; CCI approval obtained on 08.12.2020 before voting concluded; Ebix Singapore and Amtek Auto support binding nature of approved plan.
Dissenting Financial Creditors (Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI, SIDBI): Plan violates Section 30(2)(b) per Jaypee Kensington - payment must be in money, not NCDs; discrepancy between Form H and distribution sheet; CCI approval not obtained prior to CoC vote; CoC not functus officio; asset maximisation principle supports remittal.
Committee of Creditors: CIRP conducted fairly; NCLT/NCLAT recorded low plan value and high haircut; CoC sought reconsideration after NCLAT interim order; CoC has inherent power to reconsider; commercial wisdom paramount but must comply with statutory safeguards.
Promoter (Venugopal Dhoot): VIL is original acquirer of foreign oil/gas assets; subsidiaries are bare trustees under Beneficial Ownership Agreements; lenders admitted claims of Rs. 23,120.90 crores (~40.2% of claims) relating to these assets; SBI transferred VIL's VOVL shares to sequester assets; corporate veil should be lifted per Alpha Corp Development; CIRPs of VIL and VOVL should be sent back together with assets included.
VIL Vendors Association: Supported promoter; NCLAT ignored Beneficial Ownership Agreements and lenders' minutes; corporate veil should be lifted; CoC bound to maximise value (assets valued at USD 7.02 billion); same lenders would recover twice on same claims.
CoC (Reply): Promoter took contradictory stands - requested release of VIL as co-obligor (21.11.2016, 17.01.2017), consented to monetisation (20.12.2018), Section 12A proposal excluded offshore assets, rejected by 98.14%; assets excluded by Explanation (b) to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d); promoter estopped; BPRL transaction approved by VOVL CoC at 99.96%.
BPRL: Exercised pre-existing ROFR under QHA; invested ~USD 1,092 million; paid ~USD 151 million to cure VEBL defaults; transaction concluded 02.07.2026; VINI lost Indonesian interest due to 2019 defaults.
Pertamina: VINI's 23% Nunukan interest deemed transferred on 11.07.2019 upon default, formally effected 08.07.2026; VINI incorporated in Cayman Islands, Code inapplicable; assets outside India reachable only through Sections 234-235; moratorium extended only to VIL's VOVL shares.
Relief Sought
- SRA: Set aside NCLAT judgment dated 05.01.2022; restore NCLT approval order dated 08.06.2021; alternatively, remit only SRA's existing plan for reconsideration with specific defects identified within fixed timeline.
- Dissenting Creditors: Uphold NCLAT's remittal order; declare plan non-compliant with Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b).
- Promoter: Set aside NCLAT judgment dated 14.05.2026; restore NCLT order dated 12.02.2020 including foreign assets in VIL's CIRP; direct fresh Information Memorandum with assets included.
- VIL Vendors Association: Permission to appeal; set aside impugned judgment; restore 12.02.2020 order.
The Legal Issue
The central questions were: (i) What is the nature and extent of NCLT and NCLAT jurisdiction over a resolution plan approved by the CoC? (ii) Whether NCLAT has power to remit a non-compliant resolution plan to the CoC? (iii) Whether the resolution plan complied with Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b) regarding payment to dissenting financial creditors, and whether NCLT could cure the deficiency by directing cash payment? (iv) Whether CCI approval under proviso to Section 31(4) was obtained? (v) Whether CoC becomes functus officio upon approving a resolution plan? (vi) Whether CoC can revisit its approval decision? (vii) Whether foreign oil and gas assets held through subsidiaries can be included in the holding company's CIRP?
Arguments Presented
For the Appellant (SRA / Twinstar Technologies)
Senior counsel Guru Krishna Kumar argued that the CoC becomes functus officio upon approving a resolution plan under Section 30(4), relying on Ebix Singapore v. Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions and Committee of Creditors of Amtek Auto v. Dinkar T. Venkatasubramanian. He contended the Code is a sui generis statute where principles from other statutes cannot be imported. The resolution plan, approved by 95.09% voting share, exceeds liquidation value (Rs. 2,962.02 crores vs Rs. 2,568.13 crores) and haircut is a commercial decision non-justiciable per K. Sashidhar v. Indian Overseas Bank and Essar Steel. CCI approval was obtained on 08.12.2020 before voting concluded on 11.12.2020. NCLAT's remittal for fresh expressions of interest intrudes on CoC's commercial wisdom. Alternatively, if remittal is directed, it should be confined to the existing plan per Jaiprakash Associates v. IDBI Bank.
For the Respondents (Bank of Maharashtra, CoC, Promoter, et al.)
Bank of Maharashtra (ASG N. Venkataraman): Plan violates Section 30(2)(b) per Jaypee Kensington - "payment" means money only, not NCDs redeemable over six years. Discrepancy between Form H (Rs. 105.23 crores) and SBI Caps calculation (Rs. 114.21 crores) indicates misinformation to CoC. CCI approval not obtained prior to CoC vote, violating proviso to Section 31(4) per Independent Sugar Corporation v. Girish Sriram Juneja. CoC not functus officio; power to reconsider inherent per Kalyani Transco v. Bhushan Power & Steel. Asset maximisation principle provides additional ground for remittal.
Committee of Creditors (SG Tushar Mehta): CoC acts as custodian of public trust with duty of care, fairness, transparency. NCLAT has ample power to remit for reconsideration in larger public interest per Jaypee Kensington, Essar Steel, Rajputana Properties v. UltraTech Cement, and Binani Industries v. Bank of Baroda. Power to approve carries incidental power to reconsider. CoC remains in existence throughout CIRP; not an adjudicatory authority to which functus officio applies. Ebix and Amtek Auto concerned resolution applicant withdrawal, not CoC reconsideration post-stay of approval. Kalyani Transco affirms CoC continues until plan implementation or liquidation.
Promoter (K.K. Venugopal, Gopal Sankaranarayanan): VIL acquired foreign assets via MoU with BPCL; subsidiaries are SPVs holding assets as bare trustees under Beneficial Ownership Agreements (2008, 2010, 2015). Lenders admitted Rs. 23,120.90 crores claims relating to these assets. SBI transferred VIL's VOVL shares to SBICAP Trustee (13.03.2018) to sequester assets - fraud on process. NCLAT dismissed appeal No. 650/2021 without dealing with contentions. Corporate veil should be lifted per Alpha Corp Development v. Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority.
The Court's Analysis
Jurisdiction of NCLT and NCLAT
The Court examined Sections 30, 31, and 61 of the Code. Section 30(2) mandates RP to examine each plan for compliance with clauses (a) to (f). Section 30(4) empowers CoC to approve by 66% vote after considering feasibility, viability, and distribution manner per Section 53 priority. Section 31(1) requires Adjudicating Authority to approve if satisfied plan meets Section 30(2) requirements. Section 31(2) mandates rejection if non-compliant. Section 61(3) enumerates specific grounds for appeal against approval order.
The Court held the statutory scheme identifies NCLT and NCLAT as adjudicatory bodies, not mere approving authorities. As held in K. Sashidhar and Essar Steel, they cannot interfere on merits with CoC's commercial decision nor rewrite/modify a resolution plan. Their jurisdiction is confined to verifying compliance with Section 30(2) and the grounds in Section 61(3).
Power of NCLAT to Remit
The Court affirmed NCLAT's power to remit a non-compliant plan to CoC. An express statutory power carries incidental powers necessary for effective exercise. Neither NCLT nor NCLAT can modify a plan or substitute commercial judgment. Rejecting a plan under Section 31(2) may trigger liquidation under Section 33(1)(b) - a last resort. The power to remit is recognised in Jaypee Kensington (para 170-172) and Essar Steel (para 73), where the Court held the appropriate course is to send the plan back to CoC for modification and revoting. Rule 11 of NCLAT Rules, 2016 preserves inherent powers to meet ends of justice.
The 2026 Amendment inserting a proviso to Section 31(2) - requiring notice to CoC to rectify defects before rejection - gives statutory expression to this principle, confirming legislative policy favouring remittance over rejection.
Compliance with Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b)
The Court analysed the resolution plan's payment structure: upfront Rs. 200 crores to financial creditors as a class, and NCDs of Rs. 2,700 crores at 6.65% coupon redeemable over six years. Dissenting creditors were not carved out for money payment; their entitlement was worked within the same instruments with mere priority of redemption a day before assenting creditors.
Relying on Jaypee Kensington (three-Judge Bench), the Court held "payment" under Section 30(2)(b) means payment in money only. A dissenting financial creditor cannot be forced to remain attached via equities or securities. The expression 'payment' refers only to money, not barter equivalents. A plan discharging dissenting creditors through debentures redeemable over six years does not provide for "payment" within Section 30(2)(b).
Clause 3.5.7's general stipulation of compliance with law cannot substitute a specific provision for how, when, and in what form dissenting creditors will be paid. Compliance must be found in the plan's terms, not in an undertaking to comply.
Regulation 38(1)(b) secures priority to dissenting financial creditors over assenting ones. The plan did not secure this right, violating the Regulation.
Thus, the plan contravenes Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b), constituting contravention of "any law for the time being in force" under Section 61(3)(i), making out a ground for interference.
NCLT's Direction for Cash Payment
The NCLT's direction to pay dissenting creditors liquidation value in cash upfront altered the payment structure and order of disbursement among financial creditors. This was a substantive modification of the resolution plan, impermissible as only CoC can alter a plan by requisite vote under Section 30(4). The deficiency could not be cured by NCLT, notwithstanding CoC counsel's statement.
CCI Approval
The SRA placed on record CCI communication dated 08.12.2020 showing approval obtained before voting concluded on 11.12.2020. The Court held requirement of proviso to Section 31(4) was complied with.
CoC Not Functus Officio
The Court held CoC is not an adjudicatory authority but a body of creditors (mostly public sector banks) entrusted with commercial decisions. It acts as custodian of public trust, owes duty of care, and must act fairly and transparently. Kalyani Transco (three-Judge Bench) rejected functus officio argument, holding: (i) resolution plan does not attain finality until Sections 61/62 appeals decided; (ii) Explanation to Regulation 18(2) CIRP Regulations provides CoC continues until plan implementation or liquidation order; (iii) holding CoC functus officio would leave creditors remediless if plan cannot be implemented or is set aside.
CoC's Power to Revisit
The Court distinguished Ebix and Amtek Auto - both concerned resolution applicant seeking to withdraw/modify post-approval, not CoC reconsideration after statutory appeal stay. K.N. Rajakumar concerned Section 12A withdrawal. Kalpraj Dharamshi affirmed CoC's commercial wisdom primacy - which here was exercised in favour of reconsideration. Bank of India v. S.M. Kamal Pasha (2026) recognised reconsideration may be directed to ensure Section 30(2) compliance, though it termed CoC's unilateral withdrawal "shortsighted opportunism".
Here, the plan was found to contravene Section 30(2)(b), approval set aside in statutory appeal, and CoC sought reconsideration by 95% majority after NCLAT's interim order restoring status quo ante. The CoC was well within its right to revisit.
Foreign Oil and Gas Assets - Subsidiary Assets Excluded
The Court held VIL does not hold direct interest in Brazilian/Indonesian assets but through subsidiaries VOVL and VHHL. Section 18 Explanation (b) expressly excludes "assets of any Indian or foreign subsidiary of the corporate debtor" from the corporate debtor's assets. Section 36(4)(d) similarly excludes subsidiary assets from liquidation estate. These provisions recognise the settled principle that holding and subsidiary are distinct legal persons; holding company does not own subsidiary's assets (Vodafone International Holdings v. Union of India).
The Promoter's conduct estops him from claiming inclusion: (i) requested release of VIL as co-obligor (21.11.2016, 17.01.2017); (ii) actively participated in valuation/monetisation; (iii) Section 12A proposal expressly kept offshore assets out; (iv) did not challenge NCLAT stay of 19.02.2020; (v) did not object to resolution plan; (vi) consolidation application (M.A. 3944/2019) dismissed for non-prosecution on 09.02.2022, attaining finality; (vii) earlier consolidation application did not pray for inclusion of foreign subsidiaries.
Beneficial Ownership Agreements are intra-group arrangements not transferring assets to holding company. Lenders' correspondence/admissions cannot confer title absent document showing transfer. Alpha Corp principle of substance over form cannot override statutory exclusion in Explanation (b) to Section 18. LIC v. Escorts does not assist - corporate veil lifted to prevent fraud/statutory evasion, but here statute itself excludes subsidiary assets without qualification on source of acquisition.
Haircut and valuation are within CoC's commercial wisdom, non-justiciable per K. Sashidhar and Essar Steel. Section 12A proposal rejected by 98.14% unchallenged. Fraud allegations lack particulars; pledge invocation was pre-insolvency enforcement; challenge lies under Code before Adjudicating Authority.
VOVL's CIRP: BPRL exercised pre-existing ROFR under QHA; transaction approved by VOVL CoC at 99.96% and NCLT; concluded 02.07.2026; BPRL funded VEBL defaults for years. Promoter has no locus to question. VIL Vendors Association's grievance derivative; operational creditors recover from VIL's estate; foreign assets not part of it. Remedy for pre-insolvency transactions lies under Sections 43-51, 66 before Adjudicating Authority.
Guardrails on Remand Power
The Court articulated considerations to guide NCLAT when remanding: (a) Remand only in furtherance of Code objectives: going concern, fair recovery, value maximisation, time-bound resolution. (b) Must rest on finding of legal non-compliance under Section 30(2) or Section 61(3)(i). (c) Exercise sparingly, with circumspection, consistent with limitations on inherent powers. (d) Corrective function: where Adjudicating Authority modifies plan instead of remitting, NCLAT may remand to restore role allocation. (e) Strict direction to adhere to Code timelines so remedy does not become source of delay.
The Verdict
The Supreme Court dismissed all appeals. In Group I (Civil Appeal Nos. 894, 512, 509 of 2022), the Court upheld NCLAT's judgment dated 05.01.2022 setting aside the resolution plan approval and remitting to CoC, holding the plan violated Section 30(2)(b) by providing NCDs instead of money payment to dissenting financial creditors, and violated Regulation 38(1)(b) by not securing priority to dissenting creditors. NCLT's cash payment direction was an impermissible modification. CCI approval was obtained on 08.12.2020 before voting concluded. CoC does not become functus officio and was entitled to reconsider its approval after NCLAT's interim stay. No costs awarded.
In Group II (Civil Appeal No. 1307 of 2022, Civil Appeal Nos. 8659 - 8661, 8718 - 8719 of 2026, Civil Appeal @ Diary Nos. 41234 and 41286 of 2026), the Court upheld NCLAT's judgment dated 14.05.2026, holding foreign oil and gas assets held through subsidiaries cannot be included in VIL's CIRP per Explanation (b) to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d). Promoter estopped by contradictory conduct. Beneficial Ownership Agreements and lenders' admissions cannot override statutory exclusion. Alpha Corp inapplicable. VOVL's CIRP and BPRL's ROFR exercise upheld. VIL Vendors Association granted liberty to pursue remedies under law. No costs awarded. All interlocutory applications disposed of.
What This Means For Similar Cases
NCLAT Remittal Power Is Statutorily Recognised and Purpose-Bound
- The power to remit a non-compliant resolution plan to the CoC is not merely implied but now statutorily recognised through the 2026 Amendment to Section 31(2). Practitioners should expect remittal as the default remedy for Section 30(2) defects rather than outright rejection.
- Remittal must be grounded in a specific finding of legal non-compliance under Section 30(2) or Section 61(3)(i). NCLAT cannot remit based on commercial dissatisfaction with the plan's value or haircut.
- Any remittal order must include strict timelines for CoC action to prevent the remedy from becoming a source of delay contrary to the Code's time-bound resolution objective.
"Payment" to Dissenting Creditors Means Money Only - No Equivalents
- Jaypee Kensington is now firmly entrenched: Section 30(2)(b) requires payment in money to dissenting financial creditors. NCDs, equity, or any security instruments do not satisfy this requirement regardless of coupon rate, priority, or redemption schedule.
- A general compliance clause ("payment shall be as per Section 30(2)(b)") cannot cure the absence of a specific money-payment mechanism for dissenting creditors in the plan terms.
- Regulation 38(1)(b) priority must be structurally embedded in the payment waterfall, not merely stated as a principle.
CoC Remains Active Until Plan Implementation or Liquidation
- The CoC does not become functus officio upon Section 30(4) approval. It continues to exist and exercise powers throughout the CIRP, including the power to reconsider its approval, especially when the plan's legality is under challenge in statutory appeals.
- CoC's reconsideration power is inherent in its statutory role as custodian of public trust and is not negated by the binding effect of an approved plan - which presupposes a compliant plan.
- Practitioners advising CoCs should note that a stay of the approval order (as occurred here on 19.07.2021) restores the pre-approval position and keeps the process open for CoC action.
Subsidiary Assets Are Statutorily Excluded from Holding Company's CIRP
- Explanation (b) to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d) create a bright-line rule: assets of any Indian or foreign subsidiary are excluded from the corporate debtor's estate, regardless of beneficial ownership arrangements, intra-group agreements, or lenders' admissions.
- The corporate veil cannot be lifted to override this statutory exclusion. Alpha Corp and LIC v. Escorts are limited to fraud/statutory evasion contexts and do not apply where the statute itself expressly excludes subsidiary assets without qualification.
- Promoters and creditors cannot approbate and reprobate: conduct such as requesting exclusion of assets, submitting Section 12A proposals excluding them, and failing to challenge interim orders excluding them creates estoppel against later claiming inclusion.
Practical Takeaways for Resolution Plan Drafting
- Dissenting creditor payout: Structure a dedicated cash payment mechanism for dissenting financial creditors meeting liquidation value, separate from the assenting creditors' instruments.
- Regulation 38(1)(b) compliance: Ensure the payment waterfall explicitly prioritises dissenting financial creditors over assenting ones in actual disbursement sequence.
- CCI approval timeline: Obtain CCI approval before CoC voting concludes; maintain documentary evidence of timing.
- CoC resolutions: Document CoC's consideration of feasibility, viability, asset maximisation, and stakeholder balance in approval minutes to withstand judicial review.
- Subsidiary asset claims: If assets are held through subsidiaries, pursue inclusion through the subsidiary's own CIRP or pre-insolvency avoidance applications (Sections 43-51, 66), not through holding company's CIRP.
