
The Madras High Court has clarified that daughters born after a partition become coparceners in their father's reserved share by virtue of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, rendering a subsequent settlement deed by the father invalid as to ancestral property. The Division Bench recalculated partition shares for a joint family property in Chennai, applying principles of coparcenary and succession under Sections 6, 8, and 15 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The litigation originated from a suit for partition (CS No. 662/2010) concerning the J-Schedule property - a bungalow with 25 grounds of land at Door No. 21/57, Dr. Azhagappa Road, Purasawalkam, Chennai - kept as undivided common property under a partition deed dated 13.12.1956 (Ex.P.6) executed by T.G. Vellaya Nadar (father) and his six sons, wife, mother, and two daughters. By the time the suit was filed, 21 grounds had been sold, leaving only 4 grounds and 7 square feet (9,607 sq ft) for partition. Three appeals challenged the Single Judge's preliminary decree dated 06.04.2018.
Key Facts
- 13.12.1956: Partition deed (Ex.P.6) registered as Document No. 12/1957; J-Schedule property (25 grounds) allotted to father Vellaya Nadar and six sons (Defendants 1, 3, 4, 7, 8, 9 and pre-deceased sons Vijayakumar and Shanmugam), each entitled to 1/7th share.
- 1957 - 1973: 21 grounds from J-Schedule sold jointly by father and sons.
- Post-1956 births: Plaintiffs 1 and 3 (daughters), Defendants 2, 4, 5, 9 (sons) born after partition.
- 02.07.2009: Registered Power of Attorney executed by plaintiffs and Defendants 1 - 10 for sale of Tharangambadi properties; sale proceeds distributed equally.
- 08.04.2010: Agreement for sale (Doc. No. 1308/2010) by Defendants 1 - 4, 6 - 9 to Defendants 11 - 13 (subsequent purchasers) for Rs. 2,40,00,000; possession handed over.
- 13.04.2010: Agreement for sale and General Power of Attorney by Defendants 1 and 8 to Defendants 11 - 13.
- 16.04.2010: General Power of Attorney by Defendants 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 9 to Defendants 11 - 13.
- 06.03.2006: Settlement deed (Ex.D.2) by Vellaya Nadar settling his 1/7th share in J-Schedule and G-Schedule properties to sons and grandsons; daughters entitled to 2% of sale consideration.
- 28.11.2005: Settlement deed (Ex.D.4) by Thanalakshmi (mother) settling 522 sq ft (out of 1,372.43 sq ft inherited from her unmarried son Shanmugam) to Defendants 4 and 7.
- 10.05.2006: Death of Vellaya Nadar.
- 19.07.2006: Death of Thanalakshmi.
- 21.02.2012: Issues framed by Single Judge.
- 06.04.2018: Preliminary decree by Single Judge granting 307/10584 shares each to after-born children.
Procedural History
- CS No. 662/2010: Suit for partition filed by Plaintiffs 1 - 3.
- 06.04.2018: Judgment and preliminary decree by Single Judge.
- OSA No. 390/2018: Appeal by Plaintiffs (Appellants 1 - 5) challenging share calculation.
- OSA No. 370/2018: Appeal by Defendants 2, 3, 6, 7, 9 (Appellants 1 - 5) challenging decree.
- OSA No. 304/2018: Appeal by Defendants 11 - 13 (subsequent purchasers) challenging decree.
- 04.11.2026: Arguments reserved.
- 13.11.2026: Common judgment pronounced by Division Bench.
Relief Sought
- Plaintiffs (OSA 390): Correct share calculation; each after-born child entitled to 334.30 sq ft; second plaintiff and 10th defendant entitled to 105.57 sq ft each; divided sons entitled to 1,478 sq ft each.
- Defendants 2,3,6,7,9 (OSA 370): Dismiss suit for improper court fee and lack of joint possession; uphold settlement deeds Ex.D.2 and Ex.D.4; deny plaintiffs' share.
- Subsequent purchasers (OSA 304): Dismiss suit; uphold settlement deeds; protect bona fide purchase for Rs. 2,40,00,000 during pendency of suit.
The Legal Issue
The central questions were: (1) Whether after-born children (including daughters post-2005 Amendment) can reopen the 1956 partition to claim coparcenary rights in the father's reserved 1/7th share; (2) Whether the settlement deeds dated 28.11.2005 (Ex.D.4) and 06.03.2006 (Ex.D.2) are valid and binding on after-born coparceners; (3) The correct ratio of shares each party is entitled to in the remaining 9,607 sq ft.
Arguments Presented
For the Appellants in OSA No. 390 (Plaintiffs)
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P.M. Subramanian submitted that the Single Judge's share calculation was erroneous. Under Bhagwat Ram v. Ramji Ram (AIR 1947 PC 140) and Mulla's Hindu Law, after-born sons become coparceners with the father in his reserved share. By virtue of Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (as amended by Act 39 of 2005), daughters also become coparceners. The father's 1/7th share in J-Schedule property thus devolved upon all after-born children as coparceners, not equally among all legal heirs. The share of pre-deceased son Shanmugam (1/7th) devolved on mother Thanalakshmi and then to all legal heirs under Section 15.
For the Appellants in OSA No. 370 (Defendants 2,3,6,7,9)
Mr. K. Bijai Sundar contended that the Single Judge failed to properly consider Ex.D.2 (father's settlement) and Ex.D.4 (mother's settlement). The settlements were acted upon, as evidenced by the 2009 Power of Attorney referencing the father's settlement. The plaintiffs were never in joint possession, so court fee under Section 37(1) of the Tamil Nadu Court-Fees and Suits Valuation Act, 1955 was payable, making the suit non-maintainable.
For the Appellants in OSA No. 304 (Subsequent Purchasers)
Mr. K.V. Bhashyam Chari argued plaintiffs lacked joint possession; court fee issue was not decided; appellants are bona fide purchasers for Rs. 2,40,00,000 during lis pendens; father's settlement deed (Ex.D.2) was acted upon and binds plaintiffs.
The Court's Analysis
The Division Bench, per Justice N. Sathish Kumar, examined the rights of after-born children under Hindu law. Relying on Bhagwat Ram v. Ramji Ram and Mulla's Hindu Law (22nd Ed., para 309), the Court held that where a father reserves a share at partition, after-born sons become coparceners with him in that share, excluding divided sons. The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 (effective 09.09.2005) elevated daughters to coparcener status "by birth" under amended Section 6. Since the father's 1/7th share in J-Schedule property was reserved in 1956, after-born children (Plaintiffs 1, 3 and Defendants 2, 4, 5, 9) became coparceners in that share.
"Therefore, from the above, it is clear that in any property which is reserved by the father, the after born son will become coparcener with the father and the divided son will be excluded. Admittedly, in the case on hand, the parties are claiming shares only in respect of 4 grounds and 7 square feet... the three daughters, namely plaintiffs 1 and 3 and 5th defendant were born after the partition. It is relevant to note that after the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 [39 of 2005], the daughters also elevated to the status of a coparcener as that of the sons."
The Court held Ex.D.2 (father's settlement dated 06.03.2006) invalid as to ancestral property because: (a) once after-born children became coparceners, one coparcener (father) could not unilaterally settle joint family property; (b) the settlement was executed after the cut-off date 20.12.2004 under Act 39 of 2005. However, Ex.D.4 (mother's settlement dated 28.11.2005) was valid for 522 sq ft - this represented her separate property inherited as Class I heir from her unmarried son Shanmugam (1/7th share = 1,372.43 sq ft), devolvable under Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act.
The Court recalculated shares from the 9,607 sq ft:
- Father's 1/7th share = 1,372.43 sq ft. After-born children (6 persons) each get 1/7th of this = 196.06 sq ft (coparcenary).
- Remaining 196.06 sq ft of father's 1/7th divided among 14 Class I heirs (13 children + mother) = 14.004 sq ft each under Section 8.
- Mother Thanalakshmi inherited 1,372.43 sq ft from Shanmugam + 14.004 sq ft from husband = 1,386.43 sq ft. Less 522 sq ft gifted via Ex.D.4 = 864.43 sq ft divided among 13 legal heirs = 66.49 sq ft each under Section 15.
- After-born children total: 196.06 + 14.004 + 66.49 = 276.55 sq ft each.
- Divided sons (D1, D3, D6, D7): 1,372.43 (partition) + 14.004 (Section 8) + 66.49 (Section 15) = 1,452.924 sq ft each.
- Legal heirs of D8 (D14 - 17): together 1,452.924 sq ft.
- 2nd Plaintiff & 10th Defendant (daughters born before partition): not coparceners; only 14.004 + 66.49 = 80.49 sq ft each.
- Ex.D.4 gift: 522 sq ft to D4 & D7.
The Verdict
The Division Bench modified the preliminary decree dated 06.04.2018. OSA Nos. 304 and 370 of 2018 were partly allowed; OSA No. 390 of 2018 was disposed of. No costs awarded. Connected miscellaneous petitions closed. The Court passed a fresh preliminary decree allocating shares as follows: Plaintiffs 1 & 3 and Defendants 2, 4, 5, 9 - 276.55 sq ft each (total 1,659.30 sq ft); Defendants 1, 3, 6, 7 - 1,452.924 sq ft each (total 5,811.69 sq ft); Defendants 14 - 17 (heirs of D8) - 1,452.924 sq ft together; 2nd Plaintiff and 10th Defendant - 80.49 sq ft each (total 160.98 sq ft); Gift per Ex.D.4 - 522 sq ft to Defendants 4 & 7. Total: 9,606.90 sq ft. Parties directed to work out shares per this ratio and pay necessary court fee for final decree.
What This Means For Similar Cases
After-Born Daughters Are Coparceners In Father's Reserved Share
- The 2005 Amendment operates retrospectively to confer coparcenary status by birth on daughters born after a partition where the father reserved a share.
- Such daughters can claim partition of the father's reserved share alongside after-born sons, to the exclusion of divided sons.
- Practitioners must identify: (a) whether father reserved a share at original partition; (b) dates of birth of daughters relative to partition and 09.09.2005; (c) whether the property in dispute falls within the father's reserved share.
Settlement Deeds By One Coparcener Cannot Bind Others
- Once after-born children become coparceners in ancestral property, no single coparcener (including the father) can execute a valid settlement deed disposing of the joint family property.
- Settlement deeds executed after 20.12.2004 (cut-off date under Act 39 of 2005) are particularly vulnerable to challenge by daughters claiming coparcenary rights.
- However, a mother's settlement of her separate property (e.g., inherited from a pre-deceased son under Section 15) remains valid and binding.
Share Calculation Requires Layered Succession Analysis
- Courts must separately compute: (a) coparcenary shares in father's reserved portion; (b) succession to father's remaining interest under Section 8; (c) succession to mother's inherited property under Section 15.
- Quantified relief: In this case, after-born children received 276.55 sq ft each; divided sons received 1,452.924 sq ft each; pre-partition daughters received only 80.49 sq ft each.
- Practitioners should prepare detailed share computation charts tracing each devolution step for appellate advocacy.
Lis Pendens Does Not Protect Subsequent Purchasers Against Co-Owners
- Purchase during pendency of partition suit does not bind non-consenting co-owners.
- Court fee objections not seriously raised at trial (no application filed, co-owners not examined as witnesses) cannot be raised for the first time at appellate stage.
- Possession by one co-owner is deemed possession of all; evasive denials in written statements without evidence are insufficient to defeat joint possession.
Key Takeaways for Drafting and Litigation
- In partition suits involving pre-2005 partitions with reserved father's shares, always plead coparcenary rights of after-born daughters under amended Section 6.
- Challenge settlement deeds by fathers post-20.12.2004 as invalid against after-born coparceners.
- Distinguish between ancestral property (father's reserved share) and separate property (mother's inheritance from pre-deceased son) - different succession rules apply.
- Ensure court fee is paid correctly: joint possession by one co-owner suffices for ad valorem fee under Section 37(1); defendants must file specific application to challenge valuation.






