
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Indore, has reaffirmed that the denial of foreign tax credit solely due to belated filing of Form 67 violates the substantive rights granted under double taxation avoidance agreements. This judgment reinforces that procedural lapses cannot override statutory and treaty-based entitlements, offering critical clarity for taxpayers and practitioners navigating FTC claims.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The assessee, an individual taxpayer, claimed foreign tax credit (FTC) of Rs. 4,20,823 under Section 90/90A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for taxes paid in a foreign jurisdiction during Assessment Year 2021-22. The claim was denied by the Assessing Officer (AO) because Form 67 - required under Rule 128(9) of the Income-tax Rules - was not filed at the time of return filing. The taxpayer had, however, electronically filed Form 67 on the same day as the return (27.12.2021) but mistakenly selected Assessment Year 2020-21 instead of 2021-22. Upon discovering the error, the taxpayer filed a corrected Form 67 on 16.12.2024 and applied for rectification under Section 154.
Procedural History
- 27.12.2021: Assessee filed income tax return and e-filed Form 67 with incorrect AY (2020-21)
- 12.05.2022: AO issued intimation under Section 143(1) denying FTC due to non-filing of Form 67 for AY 2021-22
- 16.12.2024: Assessee filed corrected Form 67 for AY 2021-22 and applied for rectification under Section 154
- 06.03.2025: CIT(A) dismissed rectification application
- 19.02.2026: ITAT Indore heard appeal and allowed it
Relief Sought
The assessee sought reversal of the AO’s order and direct grant of FTC under Section 90/90A, arguing that the error was technical, inadvertent, and did not affect the substance of the claim.
The Legal Issue
The central question was whether the failure to file Form 67 on or before the due date under Section 139(1) renders the claim for foreign tax credit under Section 90/90A invalid, or whether such filing is a directory requirement that does not extinguish a substantive right granted by treaty.
Arguments Presented
For the Appellant/Petitioner
The assessee’s advocate argued that:
- Form 67 filing is a procedural, directory requirement under Rule 128(9), not a mandatory condition for entitlement to FTC
- The DTAA overrides domestic procedural rules, and the right to FTC under Article 24 of the treaty is a vested right
- The error was bona fide and inadvertent, with identical FTC figures in both filings
- Precedents from ITAT Bangalore (Brinda Ramkrishna, Deepak Shimoga Padmaraju) and Madras High Court (Duraiswamy Kumaraswamy) consistently hold that belated filing does not defeat FTC
- Section 295(2)(ha) empowers CBDT to prescribe procedure, but not to deny substantive rights
For the Respondent/State
The Revenue did not contest the legal arguments but requested that any grant of relief be subject to verification by the AO to ensure accuracy of the claim.
The Court's Analysis
The Tribunal examined the nature of Rule 128(9) and its relationship with Section 90/90A and applicable DTAA provisions. It emphasized that while the Rule prescribes a timeline for filing Form 67, it does not contain any express provision for disallowance of FTC in case of delay. The Court noted that other sections of the Act, such as Section 80IA(7) and Section 10A(5), explicitly deny deductions for non-compliance - language conspicuously absent in Rule 128.
"The mere fact that it is statutory does not matter one way or the other. There are conditions and conditions. Some may be substantive, mandatory and based on considerations of policy and some others may merely belong to the area of procedure."
The Tribunal relied on the Supreme Court’s reasoning in Mangalore Chemicals & Fertilizers Ltd. and Sambhaji v. Gangabai, affirming that procedures are "handmaids of justice," not its masters. It further held that DTAA provisions, particularly Article 24(4)(a), create a substantive right to FTC, which cannot be nullified by a procedural rule. The Tribunal also cited its own coordinate bench’s decision in Asha Rani Pandya and the consistent view of Bangalore Benches, concluding that the issue was not debatable but settled.
The Court accepted that the taxpayer’s error was technical and unintentional, with no evidence of fraud or concealment. The identical figures in both filings confirmed the taxpayer’s consistent intent to claim FTC for AY 2021-22. The Tribunal held that denying relief on such grounds would violate the principle of substantial justice over technicality, as affirmed in Katiji.
The Verdict
The assessee won. The Court held that filing of Form 67 is a directory requirement and non-compliance does not extinguish the substantive right to FTC under Section 90/90A. The AO was directed to verify the claim and grant the relief, subject to confirmation of the quantum.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Form 67 Delay Does Not Bar FTC Claims
- Practitioners can now confidently argue that belated filing of Form 67 - even years after the due date - cannot be grounds for denying FTC if the taxpayer can prove genuine intent and accurate documentation
- Rectification applications under Section 154 are viable remedies for such technical errors, even after intimation under Section 143(1)
- AO’s denial of FTC solely on Form 67 timing is legally unsustainable
DTAA Rights Prevail Over Procedural Rules
- Any domestic rule that conflicts with a DTAA’s substantive benefit is ultra vires
- Taxpayers may invoke treaty rights even where domestic rules impose stricter conditions
- Courts and tribunals must interpret Rule 128 in harmony with Section 90(2), which mandates that DTAA provisions prevail if more beneficial
Rectification Under Section 154 Is Permissible for Substantive Errors
-
Section 154 is not restricted to clerical or arithmetical errors alone
-
Where the error is apparent on record and affects a substantive right, rectification is permissible even if it requires legal reasoning
-
This judgment expands the scope of Section 154 beyond mechanical corrections to include legal misapplication of treaty rights
-
Practitioners should retain copies of all e-filing acknowledgments and supporting documents to establish timing and intent
-
In appeals, cite Asha Rani Pandya (ITAT Indore), Brinda Ramkrishna (ITAT Bangalore), and Duraiswamy Kumaraswamy (Madras HC)
-
Always request AO verification as a condition of relief - this aligns with the Court’s direction and avoids future litigation






