
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has quashed charges of murder and criminal conspiracy framed against a petitioner where the only material linking him to the crime was a supplementary statement by the complainant admitting he had learnt the petitioner's name from village sources, while the approver's statement under Section 164 CrPC and disclosure statements of co-accused consistently named a different third person. The Court held that hearsay cannot form the basis of grave suspicion required for framing charges and that the trial court acted as a post office by ignoring material evidence that excluded the petitioner.
Background & Facts
The Dispute
The petitioner, Alok Kumar Shah, filed a revision petition challenging the order dated 12.07.2016 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Kapurthala in Sessions Case No. 126 of 2014, whereby charges under Sections 302 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 were framed against him along with co-accused Rajiv Dass. The charges arose from FIR No. 69 dated 17.06.2012 registered at Police Station Sadar Phagwara, District Kapurthala, for the murder of Raghu, brother of the complainant Nathuni.
Key Facts
- 17.06.2012: FIR registered on statement of Nathuni, who ran a flower stall on Banga Road, Phagwara. He alleged his brother Raghu was murdered by Rajiv Dass and two companions on the morning of 17.06.2012 after they had stayed at the complainant's house the previous night.
- 23.06.2012: Police raid at a house in Village Tihar, Delhi recovered a driving licence of Yogesh Kumar. The complainant identified the photograph as one of the persons who had come with Rajiv Dass.
- 29.09.2012: Complainant made a supplementary statement stating he had "learnt at my own level and from my village" that the name of the second person was Alok Shah s/o Ram Sagar Shah, resident of Bishanpur, Police Station Bathnaha, District Sitamarhi.
- 12.01.2014: Petitioner arrested.
- February 2014: Yogesh Kumar surrendered before police. In his disclosure statement, he named Rajiv Dass and Bharat as his companions.
- 11.03.2014: Rajiv Dass arrested. In his disclosure statement, he named Yogesh Kumar and Bharat as companions.
- 13.10.2014: Case committed to Court of Session.
- 05.01.2016: Yogesh Kumar's application under Section 307 CrPC for pardon allowed by Additional Sessions Judge, Kapurthala.
- 15.01.2016: Yogesh Kumar's statement under Section 164 CrPC recorded by Chief Judicial Magistrate, Kapurthala. He named only himself, Rajiv Dass, and Bharat Jha as persons who had come to the motor of Raghu. He did not name the petitioner.
- 12.07.2016: Impugned order framing charges under Sections 302 and 120-B IPC against petitioner and Rajiv Dass.
- 16.11.2018: Rajiv Dass convicted under Section 302 IPC, sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life; acquitted under Section 120-B IPC.
Procedural History
- 17.06.2012: FIR No. 69 registered at PS Sadar Phagwara, District Kapurthala
- 23.06.2012: Raid in Delhi, driving licence of Yogesh Kumar found
- 29.09.2012: Complainant's supplementary statement naming petitioner
- 12.01.2014: Petitioner arrested
- February 2014: Yogesh Kumar surrendered
- 11.03.2014: Rajiv Dass arrested
- 13.10.2014: Case committed to Sessions Court
- 05.01.2016: Pardon granted to Yogesh Kumar
- 15.01.2016: Approver's Section 164 CrPC statement recorded
- 12.07.2016: Charges framed against petitioner and Rajiv Dass
- 03.10.2016: Notice of motion issued, proceedings stayed qua petitioner
- 08.10.2018: Stay clarified not to affect trial of co-accused
- 16.11.2018: Rajiv Dass convicted under Section 302 IPC
- 19.11.2018: Sentence of life imprisonment imposed on Rajiv Dass
- 13.11.2026: Present revision petition decided by High Court
Relief Sought
The petitioner sought setting aside of the impugned order dated 12.07.2016, quashing of charges framed under Sections 302 and 120-B IPC, and his discharge from the case.
The Legal Issue
The central question was whether charges under Sections 302 and 120-B IPC can be sustained against an accused when the only material connecting him to the offence is a supplementary statement of the complainant based entirely on hearsay information from unnamed village sources, while the approver's statement under Section 164 CrPC and disclosure statements of co-accused consistently name a different third person and exclude the accused.
Arguments Presented
For the Petitioner
Learned senior counsel argued that the petitioner was not named in the FIR and there was no eye-witness. The FIR described only two companions of Rajiv Dass, aged about 40 and 25 years. Investigation identified them as Yogesh Kumar and Bharat @ Pandit. The petitioner was roped in solely on the basis of the complainant's supplementary statement dated 29.09.2012, made more than three months after the occurrence, where the complainant did not claim personal knowledge but stated he had learnt the name from his village without disclosing the source. This constituted inadmissible hearsay under Section 60 of the Evidence Act. The investigating agency itself found the petitioner innocent in case diary entries (zimnis) No. 41, 41-A, and 41-B and sought his discharge, though declined by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Phagwara on 04.02.2014. The approver's Section 164 CrPC statement named only himself, Rajiv Dass, and Bharat Jha, fully accounting for both companions mentioned in the FIR. No test identification parade of the petitioner was conducted. The trial court acted as a post office of the prosecution and ignored material evidence.
For the Respondent
Learned State counsel argued that the complainant specifically named the petitioner in his supplementary statement as the third person accompanying Rajiv Dass. At the stage of framing charge, the court is only required to see whether a prima facie case is made out and evidence cannot be appreciated. The complainant, appearing as PW-2, also named the petitioner. The plea of false implication and other defences are matters for trial. The petition should be dismissed.
The Court's Analysis
The Court examined the scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC, citing Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460, holding that revisional power corrects patent errors of law or jurisdiction where the decision is grossly erroneous, based on no evidence, or material evidence has been ignored. The test for framing charges flows from Section 227 CrPC. The principles from Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal, (1979) 3 SCC 4 and Sajjan Kumar v. CBI, (2010) 9 SCC 368 were applied: the judge has power to sift and weigh evidence for the limited purpose of finding whether a prima facie case exists; where two views are possible and material gives rise to suspicion but not grave suspicion, the accused may be discharged; the court cannot act as a post office of the prosecution.
"A strong suspicion suffices. However, a strong suspicion must be founded on some material. The material must be such as can be translated into evidence at the stage of trial. The strong suspicion cannot be the pure subjective satisfaction based on the moral notions of the Judge that here is a case where it is possible that accused has committed the offence."
The Court analysed the supplementary statement of the complainant dated 29.09.2012. A plain reading showed the complainant did not claim to have identified the petitioner as the person seen with Rajiv Dass. He only stated he learnt the name "at my own level and from my village." The person who gave this information was not named, and no statement of any such person was recorded. Under Section 60 of the Evidence Act, oral evidence must be direct. Citing Kalyan Kumar Gogoi v. Ashutosh Agnihotri, (2011) 2 SCC 532, the Court held hearsay evidence is inadmissible as it carries no responsibility, truth is diluted with each repetition, and it gives scope for fraud.
The Court noted that on 23.06.2012, the complainant identified Yogesh Kumar from the driving licence photograph. On 20.02.2014, he again identified Yogesh Kumar in the police station. The petitioner was arrested on 12.01.2014, but there was no material showing the complainant identified him at any stage. No test identification parade was held.
Critically, the prosecution's own material excluded the petitioner. The FIR stated Rajiv Dass came with only two companions. Investigation identified them as Yogesh Kumar and Bharat @ Pandit. Their disclosure statements named Bharat as the third person. The approver Yogesh Kumar's Section 164 CrPC statement dated 15.01.2016 gave a complete account naming only himself, Rajiv Dass, and Bharat Jha. This statement was on record when the impugned order was passed, but the trial court merely noted its recording without considering its contents. This constituted ignoring material evidence, a recognised ground for interference in revision per Amit Kapoor.
The charge under Section 120-B IPC also lacked foundation. Apart from the bald assertion in the supplementary statement, no material showed any meeting of minds. The approver's version was that Rajiv Dass struck the blow suddenly while consuming liquor, taking the approver by surprise. Nothing connected the petitioner to the alleged motive arising from the murder of Vijay Kumar in Bihar.
The trial court's order suffered from non-application of mind. It referred generally to the police record and supplementary statement without considering whether the statement was based on personal knowledge, without discussing the approver's statement or disclosure statements of co-accused. The order even recorded that the Additional Public Prosecutor had argued there was no evidence to connect the accused and no ground for framing charge - evidently the defence submissions. Framing charge in such a mechanical manner amounted to acting as a post office of the prosecution.
The Court also noted that six prosecution witnesses were examined before the stay. The investigating officer SI Ashok Kumar (PW-1) admitted in cross-examination that except the supplementary statement, no other evidence or incriminating material came on file against the petitioner, and that the petitioner was found innocent during investigation. The complainant (PW-2) admitted in cross-examination he saw the petitioner for the first time after the occurrence when produced in court by police, and that his sister-in-law had come to know from the village about the petitioner's presence without disclosing the source. PW-2 claimed in examination-in-chief that Raghu had told him on telephone that Rajiv, Alok Shah, and Joginder were sitting with him, but this was an improvement over his earlier statements. PW-6 Shiv Nath similarly deposed the complainant had told him about the petitioner's presence, but admitted it was the first time he was naming the petitioner. These improvements were inconsistent with the supplementary statement where the complainant himself stated he had learnt the name from the village.
The Court held that identification of an accused for the first time in court after the witness has seen him in custody has little value. The defect here was not merely delay but the very nature of the material, which was inadmissible hearsay.
The Verdict
The revision petition was allowed. The impugned order dated 12.07.2016 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Kapurthala was set aside insofar as it related to the petitioner. The charges framed against the petitioner under Sections 302 and 120-B IPC were quashed and the petitioner was discharged. His bail bonds and surety bonds, if any, stand discharged. The record of the trial court was directed to be sent back forthwith along with a copy of the judgment. The Court clarified that nothing stated shall be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case against co-accused Bharat @ Pandit, who has been declared a proclaimed offender.
What This Means For Similar Cases
Hearsay Cannot Substitute Admissible Material
The judgment reinforces that at the charge framing stage, while the court does not conduct a full trial, the material must be capable of being translated into admissible evidence. A supplementary statement based entirely on unnamed village sources, where the complainant admits no personal knowledge, constitutes hearsay under Section 60 of the Evidence Act and cannot found the grave suspicion required under Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel v. State of Gujarat, (2019) 16 SCC 547. Practitioners should scrutinise the source of identification in supplementary statements and challenge charges where the sole link is unverified hearsay.
Approver's Statement Must Be Considered
When an approver's statement under Section 164 CrPC is on record before charge framing and it fully accounts for all participants in the crime excluding the accused, the trial court is bound to consider its contents. Ignoring such material evidence constitutes a patent error correctable in revision under Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander. Defence counsel must ensure the approver's statement is placed on record and specifically brought to the court's attention at the charge stage.
Mechanical Charge Framing Is Impermissible
The trial court's order merely recited the prosecution's case without engaging with the defence submissions, the approver's statement, or the disclosure statements of co-accused. The Court's observation that the order recorded the defence submissions (through the Additional Public Prosecutor's arguments) yet proceeded to frame charges demonstrates non-application of mind. Practitioners should argue that such mechanical orders violate the principles in Prafulla Kumar Samal and Sajjan Kumar requiring the court to sift evidence and not act as a post office.
- Challenge charges where the only material is a delayed supplementary statement based on hearsay
- Ensure approver's Section 164 CrPC statement is placed on record before charge arguments
- Highlight disclosure statements of co-accused that exclude the client
- Argue non-application of mind when trial court ignores material evidence
- Seek revision under Section 397 CrPC where charge framing ignores admissible material






